- Posts: 9
- Forum
- Members forums
- ESA, PIP and DLA Queries and Results
- DWP appealing First Tier Tribunal decision
× Members
DWP appealing First Tier Tribunal decision
- Tess
- Topic Author
- Offline
Less More
1 year 1 week ago #284695 by Tess
DWP appealing First Tier Tribunal decision was created by Tess
I'm putting this out here in case it helps anybody else a little. Bear with me, I suffer from extreme anxiety and am on the waiting list for an autism assessment and hopefully a diagnosis. (I have invisible disabilities. Both mental and physical). I tend to overshare or am a little ambiguous. I've tried to put this in bullet points to keep it from getting too wordy.
• I was previously on PIP at the standard rates for both daily living and mobility, I had a five-year award. On my PIP reassessment in early 2023, they only awarded me the standard mobility rate, disallowing the daily living component. They also only gave me a two-year award.
• I appealed to the First Tier Tribunal (FTT)and have recently had the decision letter, which not only ruled in my favour, but they awarded me the enhanced rates of both Mobility and Daily Living. They gave me a six-year award with backdated payments. Needless to say, I was massively relieved. During this year, my physical and mental health issues have been exacerbated by the stress of the PIP appeal and this new award was like a light opening up from the heavens. No exaggeration.
• A week or so later, I received news from the DWP saying they will still only be paying the standard rate of Mobility and nothing else because they've requested a Statement of Reasons (SoR) and will be looking to appeal. (I had the news initially over a phone call when I called to ask how long it might take. I broke down on the phone, and the other person was what I'd describe as 'coolly sympathetic'. I then received the letter after a few days.
I've been reading up where I can about how it all works with the Upper Tier Tribunal (UTT). There's mostly only information about claimants pursuing a UTT appeal, not the DWP. There isn't much information about that, but I've gleaned (from these forums mostly) that the DWP has to first request the SoR, and then can only seek permission to appeal to the UTT based on a point of law. Permission may not be granted. If it is granted, the DWP still might not win.
I'm utterly exhausted and feel like I've had the rug pulled from under me.
That was all background information... My worries are the following -
1) I was surprised to be awarded enhanced amounts for PIP, because I'd argued for my original award (standard rates of mobility and Daily Living) to be reinstated for five years. The FTT seem to have awarded me more points and a longer term than I argued for, and this did surprise me. The lady I spoke to on the phone from the DWP did keep repeating 'The DWP do not understand the award' or words to that effect.
I don't understand it either - so are the DWP probably right and they will win an appeal?
Also, the DWP letter frightens me because it states -
2) ″If we apply for permission to appeal and it is not granted we will consider if we can start paying you the additional benefit″ They'll CONSIDER it???? I thought they had to pay it if they're not given permission to appeal?
And
3) ″There is no right of appeal against the decision not to pay you additional benefit, but if it causes you hardship, please get in touch with us straight away.″ How come they can appeal and I cannot? It's all very frightening for someone with my disabilities.
• I was previously on PIP at the standard rates for both daily living and mobility, I had a five-year award. On my PIP reassessment in early 2023, they only awarded me the standard mobility rate, disallowing the daily living component. They also only gave me a two-year award.
• I appealed to the First Tier Tribunal (FTT)and have recently had the decision letter, which not only ruled in my favour, but they awarded me the enhanced rates of both Mobility and Daily Living. They gave me a six-year award with backdated payments. Needless to say, I was massively relieved. During this year, my physical and mental health issues have been exacerbated by the stress of the PIP appeal and this new award was like a light opening up from the heavens. No exaggeration.
• A week or so later, I received news from the DWP saying they will still only be paying the standard rate of Mobility and nothing else because they've requested a Statement of Reasons (SoR) and will be looking to appeal. (I had the news initially over a phone call when I called to ask how long it might take. I broke down on the phone, and the other person was what I'd describe as 'coolly sympathetic'. I then received the letter after a few days.
I've been reading up where I can about how it all works with the Upper Tier Tribunal (UTT). There's mostly only information about claimants pursuing a UTT appeal, not the DWP. There isn't much information about that, but I've gleaned (from these forums mostly) that the DWP has to first request the SoR, and then can only seek permission to appeal to the UTT based on a point of law. Permission may not be granted. If it is granted, the DWP still might not win.
I'm utterly exhausted and feel like I've had the rug pulled from under me.
That was all background information... My worries are the following -
1) I was surprised to be awarded enhanced amounts for PIP, because I'd argued for my original award (standard rates of mobility and Daily Living) to be reinstated for five years. The FTT seem to have awarded me more points and a longer term than I argued for, and this did surprise me. The lady I spoke to on the phone from the DWP did keep repeating 'The DWP do not understand the award' or words to that effect.
I don't understand it either - so are the DWP probably right and they will win an appeal?
Also, the DWP letter frightens me because it states -
2) ″If we apply for permission to appeal and it is not granted we will consider if we can start paying you the additional benefit″ They'll CONSIDER it???? I thought they had to pay it if they're not given permission to appeal?
And
3) ″There is no right of appeal against the decision not to pay you additional benefit, but if it causes you hardship, please get in touch with us straight away.″ How come they can appeal and I cannot? It's all very frightening for someone with my disabilities.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Gary
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 8169
1 year 1 week ago #284726 by Gary
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Replied by Gary on topic DWP appealing First Tier Tribunal decision
Hi Tess
Thank you for your post, we do come across fellow members in a similar situation as yourself but not very often.
You have to remember that a Tribunal is independant from the DWP and will take all your supporting documents into consideration. In their decision letter they will explain why they have awarded you the points.
Either side at a Tribunal can appeal a decision, but it has to be on a point of law, you cannot appeal just because you do not like the decision.
I have only come across it once personally when I represented a client at the tribunal which we won but DWP requested a WSOR.
Even though they requested a WSOR, they may not go ahead with an appeal to the Upper Tribunal, which happened in my case.
You need to keep checking with HMCTS once a WSOR has been issued, as DWP need to appeal within one month, once a WSOR has been issued. In my case I waited 5 weeks contacted HMCTS, no appeal had been made, I then contacted DWP legal department to see what is happening, they informed me, there was no further action being taken.
Client received all payments and backdate.
Gary
Thank you for your post, we do come across fellow members in a similar situation as yourself but not very often.
You have to remember that a Tribunal is independant from the DWP and will take all your supporting documents into consideration. In their decision letter they will explain why they have awarded you the points.
Either side at a Tribunal can appeal a decision, but it has to be on a point of law, you cannot appeal just because you do not like the decision.
I have only come across it once personally when I represented a client at the tribunal which we won but DWP requested a WSOR.
Even though they requested a WSOR, they may not go ahead with an appeal to the Upper Tribunal, which happened in my case.
You need to keep checking with HMCTS once a WSOR has been issued, as DWP need to appeal within one month, once a WSOR has been issued. In my case I waited 5 weeks contacted HMCTS, no appeal had been made, I then contacted DWP legal department to see what is happening, they informed me, there was no further action being taken.
Client received all payments and backdate.
Gary
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Tess
- Topic Author
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 9
1 year 1 week ago #284764 by Tess
Replied by Tess on topic DWP appealing First Tier Tribunal decision
Thank you, Gary. I'll try to take this as somewhat encouraging.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Moderators: Gordon, Gary, BIS, Catherine, Wendy, Kelly, greekqueen, peter, Katherine, Super User, Chris, David