A case which could make a dramatic difference to millions of legacy benefits claimants by awarding them a £20 a week backdated uplift will not be going ahead in September because, almost unbelievably, there are no judges available to hear it.

A hearing had been listed in the High Court for 28 and 29 September to decide whether the government had broken the law by awarding an additional £20 a week to universal credit claimants during the pandemic but not awarding it to claimants of legacy benefits, such as ESA.

The DWP’s excuse for this discriminatory behaviour was that the software for legacy benefits would not be able to calculate the increase for individual claimants.

However, on Friday the court announced that the case would now be adjourned until an unspecified date because no judge was available to hear it. Given the importance of the case and the huge number of people affected, this seems an extraordinary admission.

But it will come as a considerable relief to the government, which is planning to end the uplift for universal credit claimants at the end of this month, in the face of growing opposition from charities and its own MPs.

It is not known whether the case will now go ahead this year.

Comments

Write comments...
or post as a guest
People in conversation:
Loading comment... The comment will be refreshed after 00:00.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Pete · 21 hours ago
    Disgraceful roll on a labour government 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Elaine · 2 days ago
    Only a government which are millionaires would won’t a scheme like this😡 maybe another governing body need to look into and access all of their monies and what they are spending their so called hard earned cash on !! Like holidays, expenses and underhanded business deals…. And as for his comments about disabled and sick claimants are shirkers I would like to tell him that never in my life I would have ever thought that I would end up constantly unwell with health issues that can not be cured and having to live on medication for the rest of my life and that because of this I now don’t see hospital consultants and hardly get to see a GP so I feel that I will be persecuted for both ESA & Pip 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    rookie · 2 days ago
    'sup?
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    scott speirs · 2 days ago
    absolute disgrace the tories need kicking out asap
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Mrsvphil · 1 months ago
    I had a missed call this morning off a mobile number my number is relatively new and only a handful of people have it. I am awaiting a hearing date for tribunal could pip still decide to award me and if so could it be them that have tried ro call me?
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Val Peaco k · 3 months ago
    I was awarded pip indefinitely. I just happened to mention during the assessment that I had had an assessment that morning for ‘Access to Work’. The pip assessment was more or less finished once they’d heard this. If you work you really need Access to Work in to assess what can be adjusted in your place of work to ensure you can continue to work. I had adjustments made and have continued working for five years albeit having dropped a day. Access to work really are understanding and are very helpful with understanding what adjustments need to be made that you might not have considered yourself. Good luck everyone who applies for any benefits.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Angela · 15 days ago
      @Val Peaco k Can you explain more about access to work please? Thanks
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Deborah · 3 months ago
      @Val Peaco k Hello Val, can you please tell me where I would find information on Access to work. What is it and where would I go for it, would it be my employer ? 
      Tia 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Melanie Hopkins · 5 months ago
    I recently went to a tribunal to put my case to the court on how my fm affects me .My claim was unsuccessful as I hold down a job I am a nursery nurse and I could converse quite well and I can make my own way in the bus to my place of work.The fact that Im in constant pain and have had to have changes made in work to support me in my role did not matter.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      leonc1963 · 3 months ago
      @Elaine Yep Govt wants us back to work, but the DWP are working against that 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Elaine · 5 months ago
      @Melanie Hopkins I’m going through application process at the minute and was unsuccessful at first stage because I can hold down a job too; it’s almost as if they are encouraging us to give up work and become another statistic of the unemployed!
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    T · 6 months ago
    I have fibromyalgia and was awarded standard rate for daily living and nothing for mobility. The interview for pip was awful, and I was made to feel I like I was lying. Considering the government’s initiative to get disabled people into work, it’s ironic that I was not awarded mobility rate as I work part time and am able to drive to work! That was their grounds for not awarding me mobility component. I took it upon my self to apply for a blue badge and got this. Making a claim for pip is long, difficult and causes extreme anxiety. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Judy Williamson · 6 months ago
    You mention Fibromyalgia, but not M.E/Chronic Fatigue? Why not surely these go hand in hand? It frustrates me beyond believe that M.E doesn’t get the same recognition as Fibromyalgia. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Samiam · 19 days ago
      @Judy Williamson Was shocked to see no chronic pain guide, have literally watched fibro appear out of nowhere during time i have had chronic pain from complex regional pain syndrome, an easily researched condition known for over a centruy to cause severe pain.. yet i still have to prove myself every 2 or 3 yrs with ESA and this. 
       I haven't been able to work at all since early 90s but still they make me feel like a liar. I don't eat because feeding my kids with their help is too much, i shower once a week because its too painful, but i'm okay because i can adapt.!
      Why don't people with Fibro get told they can adapt to level of energy and pain when i am told to. I got stndard care, the same as a 19 yr old with ADHD socialising with his mates every weekend and at school full time. laughable really.   
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Debbie · 6 months ago
    I have fibro and anxiety,  even though  my pip review  took over a year to happen, which caused no end of stress, I was once again awarded  low rate care only. I have a blue badge because  I can't walk far, they ignored  everything,  I couldn't even be bothered to ask for a mandatory reconsideration . The whole process is awful.  I had reports from OT and a 52 page report from the top fibro guy in the country.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    MsBasset · 6 months ago
    I failed to get mobility this time around nothing has changed if anything is worse and I have Fibro/anxiety/osteo in most joints/autism and further health issues 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Tracey · 6 months ago
    Hi all, I read everyone’s posts with 100% understanding and sadness. 
    I have a phone tribunal on 2nd November and to say I am ‘terrified’ is an understatement. 
    I fight with symptoms of fibromyalgia, anxiety and depression. For years I’ve been able to push on despite high levels of pain and fatigue along with the other delights they bring. 
    In Jan 2022 I got covid. I have gone on to develop long covid which has exacerbated all previous symptoms and given me more to deal with.
    I have since been diagnosed with Rheumatoid arthritis, which I now think I’ve had for years too but put everything down to fibro, post covid asthma, chronic fatigue and I now feel I may have more mental health issues and the anxiety and depression I have are due to that. The dreaded menopause is also something I’ve finally been given treatment for. 
    The whole process of pip has, and continues to be a major strain on every aspect of my being. I am incredibly close to cancelling the tribunal as I’m not sure I can go through with it. 
    The health care assessors report was littered with manipulated inaccuracies and the dwp maintain that I am not affected on the majority of the days. This couldn’t be further away from the truth. I have to plan what I have to do in order to function and am not living… I’m literally exsisting. I can’t just do anything near to normal levels or that I would have been previously been able to do. 
    The report is full of things I simply didn’t say either. 
    I have looked at the guides and started to write more things down but when I’ve looked at my application and think about the assessment…. I have said how I am struggling but it is not being and has not been accepted, I am at a loss as to what to do.
    I also struggle to say exactly as I am due to embarrassment and feeling ashamed and failed to say somethings that I should have. My stupidity but again possibly down to mental health issues and feeling pressurised to answer things I was struggling to.
    It feels very much like I’m begging for help. After having worked in the social care field all of my working life I have helped many people. I now need some help yet can’t get it. Not that it makes any difference with what job you have had I appreciate…. It feels horrendous for everyone struggling to be heard.
    Anyone who can give me some advice would be greatly appreciated and accepted. 
    Sorry for the war and peace. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Good to know !!!! · 3 months ago
      @Sarah Paul Hi everyone my advice would be when you have your assessment weather it’s a phone call or video call or f2f tell the assessor you are recording the assessment  take a friend or family to record your assessment even if the assessor tells you they will record the assessment themselves still say I will be recording for my own evidence You have the right to record your assessment please do this you will have evidence if there are lies in the report by the assessor. And you can use the recording if it goes to tribunal. Good luck everyone.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Sarah Paul · 4 months ago
      @Tracey I felt I had to reply to your post as my heart went ont to you! I’m in the process of my 3rd pip application. I had been on incapacity benefit and when it changed to pip I was told I was looking after 2 children and so must be ok!! If only!! 
      Mine started when I was 19, working as an nanny/playgroup leader and for 5 yrs was made to feel crazy and couldn’t understand why I couldn’t stand yet alone walk! I finally got a diagnosis at 24 and given a very thin booklet (about 10 pages!) told I also had joint hyper joint flexi-mobility. 
      I’m now 53, trying again…… I’ve had 2 time extensions and am now sitting here trying to write. Thankfully there is some useful advice on here about cause and effect and thinking a bit more out of my anxious, depressed, tired, painful, brain fogged box!!
      Wish me luck!🍀 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    M.F · 6 months ago
    I did not get PIP for mobility for Fibromyalgia which I think is a disgrace
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Diana · 6 months ago
    I have claimed the old DLA and now PIP for fibromyalgia for almost 30 years. It was always very difficult and was only ever allowed for 2 years at a time before  having to claim again. 7 times I had to go  as far as tribunal. I won all but one claim and got high rate care and mobility. The one I lost was the only time I used the Welfare Rights people to help me and that was when I found Benefits and Work. 20 years ago I developed much more severe spinal problems so claiming was then easier but it wasn't until I was about to turn 65 that I finally had PIP allowed indefinitely. The allowance for 2 years only meant I could never try to get a  motability car. They seem to think that fibromyalgia is not a lifelong condition but I sent every piece of information I could; at times 11 extra pages and 3 pages listing consultants that I'd seen. The change to PIP was very worrying but went seamlessly thanks to Benefits and work and because I then had conditions that were on their list that couldn't be argued as not being permanent.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Lianne Samme · 6 months ago
    I’ve had pip for fibromyalgia since 2017, just had my renewal assessment last week so we will see how it goes 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Lyndsey · 6 months ago
      @Lianne Samme Well done you.. I now on my 4th Attempt for Fibromyalgia,  Anxiety and Depression. It's so hard to get it. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Kayte · 6 months ago
    I have fibromyalgia and first claimed in 2021. I was awarded lower rate daily living. I then put in a change of circumstance in 2023 as it had got worse, I was awarded lower rate daily living and lower rate mobility. I put in a mandatory reconsideration and sent off all my evidence from neurology, pain management, GP and other services. I was then awarded higher rate for both. I also claim ESA and was awarded the Limited work group. I found the process challenging and it gave me anxiety as I do feel they think your lying. But I am so grateful that I was awarded what I feel I am entitled too.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Sandra · 6 months ago
    I have fibromyalgia, me/cfs, chronic migraine, oesteoarthritis in hands, ibs, anxiety and other conditions and was given 0 points by PIP assessor.  I appealed but still got 0 points, I couldn’t take it to the tribunal as my anxiety was too bad.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Michelle · 1 months ago
      @Sandra This has just happened to me! It's an absolute joke. I'm also being diagnosed for PTSD but until I get a full physiological report, I get no help whatsoever.  
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Jenny · 6 months ago
    I tried and failed on several attempts claim PIP for Fibromyalgia, even went to court, which was awful experience made me like I was lying, belittled me, cross examined me,making me feel like a criminal, I gave up in end, until a friend persuaded me to do one more attempt,  which was successful,  years later.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Bugsy1943 · 7 months ago
    hi everybody, I am in the process of having my pip award reviewed ,the form is a review form it does not seem as in depth as the initial form but i am worried how i should proceed with it. It really is stressing me out could anyone advise me on how much information i should submit please? 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Bugsy1943 · 7 months ago
      @Mrs B thank you so much for your advice, think it might be too late to send for my previous application as i'm already in my extended time to complete it,i keep picking it up and then putting it down i am feeling so down at the moment with it all!!!!! 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Mrs B · 7 months ago
      @Bugsy1943 It may help you to call DWP and ask “ could you send me a copy of my previous application or review so i can compare accurately to see if anything has changed.” They are usually happy to do this. I talk to my device to type up my answers, including the heading and page number for each heading. 
      Include your name and NI number on every page, also copy and send in all the evidence letters from before plus any new ones. That way it will help you when filling further ones in as it’s already typed up, and you can also give a copy to your GP, so they know how it affects you on a daily basis if DWP write to them. Plus this can help your GP better support you. 
      If questions included on previous forms are no longer on the new form, I would still add all that information in on another page. 
      I hope this helps.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Dee · 7 months ago
    I first successfully claimed PIP in 2018 after attending a face-to-face assessment, but they only give me basic daily living.  I do also have arthritis and degenerative disc disease so I am not sure how much of the award is based on my fibromyalgia, which I have had for 14 years.  I could not face the stress of appealing even though I am in pain before I even commence walking and feel that I am entitled to the mobility element.  I successfully renewed in 2021 and have just completed the forms for my next renewal early in 2024; fingers crossed this will be successful.  As others have said, when that brown envelope comes through the letterbox the stress commences and it is hard work completing them.  I have to just do a little each day, when my health allows, until it is finished but the B&W website is so helpful with this.  It makes you realise that you are not the only one going through it.  I do feel that when you have a long term chronic condition and it is fairly obvious that not much is going to change the process should be made simpler, with maybe just an update required from the claimant's GP.  
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      MD · 7 months ago
      @Dee I wish I could help you with your form.  I used to say to my clients at the CAB. "It's not what you say in the form, yet how you write it, the words you use, also evidence, I've saved 15 years of evidence and re send it for each review process. Benefits and work have so much advice too and so I would also give clients the B&W address. 
      Don't be afraid to go to appeal, the form is online and takes 10 minutes to fill out. 
      Sending you positive energy for a positive outcome. 💐