The Milburn review final report recommends preventing claimants aged 18–24 from claiming personal independence payment (PIP) and the universal credit (UC) health element. If implemented, these benefits would be replaced with new youth benefits, leaving many young disabled people with less financial support, at least initially. In return, billions would be spent on employment and training schemes for young people, but with the threat of sanctions for those required to participate who fail to do so.
Please note: this article will be updated and amended over the coming days as we have time to work through the report in detail
The new benefits
Three new benefits are proposed:
Youth Allowance
Additional Cost Allowance
Severe and Complex Needs Insurance
The youth allowance will be means-tested and set at the current UC rate for people under 25. A higher rate will be paid to young people living independently, including care leavers and those who have experienced family estrangement. [748] A work allowance will let young people earn a certain amount before their benefits are reduced. [749]
The additional cost allowance will be a non-means-tested benefit which will replace PIP for young people “whose disability-related extra costs are significant, well established and ongoing with support better targeted at the actual extra costs they face.” [754] It will contribute towards costs such as “assistance, mobility, specialist transport, or other practical help required for daily living and independence.” [754] It will be paid regardless of whether the young person is working or not.
The severe and complex needs insurance will be paid to young people where “even maximum support will not create a realistic route to participation. This might include, for example, young people with severe or profound and multiple learning disabilities or those whose disability means they require continuous, 24-hour care and support.” [756] It will be paid at a rate above the maximum benefit rates available today. “As few people as possible should end up on this route. Intentionally it should be a very high bar.” [756]
Aids and equipment
A new local health and disability fund will be available to “pay for one-off aids and equipment or disability-related daily-living and mobility costs while the young person takes up support.” [752]
Who will be affected
Both existing claimants and new claimants will be affected by the changes.
“I believe the new system should apply to both the existing group of young people who are NEET and claiming benefits as well as the future flow of young people who end up being NEET. In both cases, however, support and opportunity will need to be put in place before benefits change.” [769]
When changes will happen
Milburn wants replacement support and opportunities in place before benefits change. He proposes phased introduction of the new benefits within this Parliament, subject to legislation, with every area having a Youth Opportunity Service or equivalent by the end of 2029. New claimants would enter the new benefits system once it is established locally. [769]
For existing claimants, the transition would normally begin six months before their scheduled reassessment for their current health or disability benefit. They would then be assessed for the new benefits. [770]
Existing claimants with the most severe disabilities should be moved to severe and complex needs insurance rapidly. “Where the state already holds evidence of profound and lifelong needs that prevent participation, the appropriate ongoing financial protection through the Severe and Complex Needs Insurance should be put in place quickly. These young people should not be left waiting to understand what the reforms mean for them personally or be required to prove again what the state already knows.” [771]
Milburn says that young people “with established and ongoing extra costs” already claiming PIP and participating in education or work should not have a period where they have reduced financial support whilst they transition to the new benefits. Instead, the aim will be to “preserve the enabling financial support on which their participation depends. They should not have to interrupt participation or demonstrate economic inactivity to secure the appropriate entitlement under the new system.” [771]
For other current claimants there will be a period of transition to “give them the space to work with their adviser, explore their choices, take up treatment, employment, functional or practical support and try real opportunities.” [772]
During this period their current health and disability related payments will continue until replacement support is in place. [773]