- Posts: 3
- Forum
- Members forums
- ESA, PIP and DLA Queries and Results
- 'They spend their free time watching TV' - I don't own a TV.
× Members
'They spend their free time watching TV' - I don't own a TV.
- ashleyp
- Topic Author
- Offline
Less More
2 years 4 months ago #273432 by ashleyp
'They spend their free time watching TV' - I don't own a TV. was created by ashleyp
Morning,
I'm going through my PIP assessment to find key points to raise with the tribunal. There's been really quite serious inaccuracies reported, including the condition and disability I have and the dates of diagnosis.
It states I was diagnosed with PTSD 3 years ago, but I was actually diagnosed with Complex PTSD in January of this year. It has reported incorrect doses of medication, the type of treatment I receive and even reported I have taken treatment that I have not (CBT).
The biggest laugh was the assessor wrote that I spent my free-time watching TV! I do not have the concentration for TV or movies. I have not owned a TV in nearly 10 years.
Apart from my personal annoyance, is this a point to raise in my response? It is making me out to be some couch potato and painting a character personality which is not-in line with the problems I experience. Anxiety is my biggest trouble, not depression.
Most of my time is lost through dissociation, or I will try reading, or I will try yoga in the house. I have to spend time doing stimulating activities. TV is not one of them.
I'm going through my PIP assessment to find key points to raise with the tribunal. There's been really quite serious inaccuracies reported, including the condition and disability I have and the dates of diagnosis.
It states I was diagnosed with PTSD 3 years ago, but I was actually diagnosed with Complex PTSD in January of this year. It has reported incorrect doses of medication, the type of treatment I receive and even reported I have taken treatment that I have not (CBT).
The biggest laugh was the assessor wrote that I spent my free-time watching TV! I do not have the concentration for TV or movies. I have not owned a TV in nearly 10 years.
Apart from my personal annoyance, is this a point to raise in my response? It is making me out to be some couch potato and painting a character personality which is not-in line with the problems I experience. Anxiety is my biggest trouble, not depression.
Most of my time is lost through dissociation, or I will try reading, or I will try yoga in the house. I have to spend time doing stimulating activities. TV is not one of them.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- BIS
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 8547
2 years 4 months ago #273454 by BIS
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Replied by BIS on topic 'They spend their free time watching TV' - I don't own a TV.
Hi ashleyp
You obviously want to concentrate your efforts on contradicting the inaccuracies that impact the PIP criteria and where you were not awarded points where you should have been. We try not to tell people not to include information unless they were going to say something that could harm their case, but your example of the TV is down to personal choice.
You say that there are a lot of inaccuracies in your report, most of which you will point out as you go along with each question. However, I would include a summary paragraph at the end, reiterating the poor quality of the report and saying that you wondered whether the assessor was writing about another claimant. It is at this point I would give the TV example. It doesn't really matter per se whether you find it a stimulating activity - but you don't have one - so the assessor was not listening. What else did they miss?
BIS
You obviously want to concentrate your efforts on contradicting the inaccuracies that impact the PIP criteria and where you were not awarded points where you should have been. We try not to tell people not to include information unless they were going to say something that could harm their case, but your example of the TV is down to personal choice.
You say that there are a lot of inaccuracies in your report, most of which you will point out as you go along with each question. However, I would include a summary paragraph at the end, reiterating the poor quality of the report and saying that you wondered whether the assessor was writing about another claimant. It is at this point I would give the TV example. It doesn't really matter per se whether you find it a stimulating activity - but you don't have one - so the assessor was not listening. What else did they miss?
BIS
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
The following user(s) said Thank You: denby, ashleyp
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- phrank
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 776
2 years 4 months ago #273466 by phrank
Replied by phrank on topic 'They spend their free time watching TV' - I don't own a TV.
Hi ashleyp,
Well, now I've heard iot all. How DO these 'people' get away with writing bare-faced lies or to try to manipulate legal documents?
I symaphise with you fully. I would definitely get your MP involved and put in a formal complaint to the DWP and the assessment provider.
This sort of thing wants wiping out.
The so-called assessors who commit such fraudulent acts should be put on public view and slapped repeatedly with cold, wet haddocks until they apologise for all the heartache they inflict upon honest, disabled and often very vulnerable human beings.
Regards,
Phrank.
Well, now I've heard iot all. How DO these 'people' get away with writing bare-faced lies or to try to manipulate legal documents?
I symaphise with you fully. I would definitely get your MP involved and put in a formal complaint to the DWP and the assessment provider.
This sort of thing wants wiping out.
The so-called assessors who commit such fraudulent acts should be put on public view and slapped repeatedly with cold, wet haddocks until they apologise for all the heartache they inflict upon honest, disabled and often very vulnerable human beings.
Regards,
Phrank.
The following user(s) said Thank You: ellen1st, denby, Sammylou40, Gary, LL26, Notyniki
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- ashleyp
- Topic Author
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 3
2 years 4 months ago #273472 by ashleyp
Replied by ashleyp on topic 'They spend their free time watching TV' - I don't own a TV.
Thanks so much, that's really helpful advice, and useful for undermining the whole report alongside the other inaccuracies.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- ashleyp
- Topic Author
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 3
2 years 4 months ago #273473 by ashleyp
Replied by ashleyp on topic 'They spend their free time watching TV' - I don't own a TV.
Thankyou Bis - that's a really good approach to undermining the quality of the report without getting to entangled with every detail of nonsense.
@phrank, I'm not sure. The report was fairly shocking. Especially as the 'reasons' for not giving me marks were:
I had told them I had literally just started and all medication was being titrated slowly due to previous allergic reactions. This wasn't reported on. Medication has now more than doubled.
But at least it provides a very easy way to argue against the 'evidence' used by simply providing a new list of prescriptions.
@phrank, I'm not sure. The report was fairly shocking. Especially as the 'reasons' for not giving me marks were:
Person is on low anti-depressant showing they function adequately
I had told them I had literally just started and all medication was being titrated slowly due to previous allergic reactions. This wasn't reported on. Medication has now more than doubled.
But at least it provides a very easy way to argue against the 'evidence' used by simply providing a new list of prescriptions.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- DJMH15
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 30
2 years 4 months ago #273492 by DJMH15
Replied by DJMH15 on topic 'They spend their free time watching TV' - I don't own a TV.
I thought that there was new guidance issued to say that it doesnt matter whether medication is taken or not. That it shouldnt have any impact on the assessment.
Sometimes it can be a symptom of an illness not to take medication, for instance in mental illnesses where there is a lack of insight. Also, maybe some of us dont want to take the medication, for our own reasons For instance, the side effects may be too much, or we may be trying to find a more holistic approach. Maybe we just dont agree with big pharma.
I feel there is a push, a drug push, element here that the dwp facilitates. I suspect alot of medication is flushed down the toilet, just so that it can be stated for purposes of getting the financial help needed. Coercive, controlling, and of course, while we are all actively taking anti depressants, or drinking the water which also contains trace elements... none of us have the capacity to uprise!
Just a thought.
Sometimes it can be a symptom of an illness not to take medication, for instance in mental illnesses where there is a lack of insight. Also, maybe some of us dont want to take the medication, for our own reasons For instance, the side effects may be too much, or we may be trying to find a more holistic approach. Maybe we just dont agree with big pharma.
I feel there is a push, a drug push, element here that the dwp facilitates. I suspect alot of medication is flushed down the toilet, just so that it can be stated for purposes of getting the financial help needed. Coercive, controlling, and of course, while we are all actively taking anti depressants, or drinking the water which also contains trace elements... none of us have the capacity to uprise!
Just a thought.
The following user(s) said Thank You: Gary
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Moderators: Gordon, Gary, BIS, Catherine, Wendy, Kelly, greekqueen, peter, Katherine, Super User, Chris, David