Ant
I think it is swings and roundabouts, a phone call may allow less transfer of information but an appointment will likely be constrained by time, so I think you need to consider which will be more effective for you.
In either case, I would make a bullet list of issues that you want to discuss with your GP so that you are as prepared as possible.
You need to be careful of putting words in your GPs mouth as it can seriously undermine anything that they may say about you to the DWP, so where possible allow them to drive the conversation. The ESA50 may be a good idea but try and find a way for it to be their idea to have a copy.
Gordon
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems