- Posts: 302
- Thank you received: 87
Members
Pip claim journey to Appeal
1 month 2 weeks ago #315839 by Sum
ΣμΜ
Replied by Sum on topic Pip claim journey to Appeal
Hi All
Just an update on Appeal
We recvd the HMCTS decision notice in post ~ 7 days after the hearing.
the Paperwork states that if i want a Stm of reasons i need to put the request in writing in post .
26 Sept I got onto the HMCTS webchat to ask for the correct email to make my request.
6 Oct i followed up on webchat to make sure my request was being dealt with. I was told the request has been passed onto the judge.
For the record of proceedings there was a bit of 'to and fro ' bec of incorrect guidance by previous advisors and a technical glitch with the HNCTS portal.
eventually i was able to access the hearing case online and download both decision notice and record of proceeding mp3 file.
Hope thats useful to someone at post appeal stage
Just an update on Appeal
We recvd the HMCTS decision notice in post ~ 7 days after the hearing.
the Paperwork states that if i want a Stm of reasons i need to put the request in writing in post .
26 Sept I got onto the HMCTS webchat to ask for the correct email to make my request.
6 Oct i followed up on webchat to make sure my request was being dealt with. I was told the request has been passed onto the judge.
For the record of proceedings there was a bit of 'to and fro ' bec of incorrect guidance by previous advisors and a technical glitch with the HNCTS portal.
eventually i was able to access the hearing case online and download both decision notice and record of proceeding mp3 file.
Hope thats useful to someone at post appeal stage
ΣμΜ
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
1 month 2 weeks ago #315840 by David
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Replied by David on topic Pip claim journey to Appeal
Hi Sum
Thanks for sharing that useful information which I have made a note of.
David
Thanks for sharing that useful information which I have made a note of.
David
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
The following user(s) said Thank You: Sum
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
1 month 2 weeks ago #315841 by Sum
ΣμΜ
Replied by Sum on topic Pip claim journey to Appeal
Record of Proceedings
I listened to the record of proceedings ... audio file only
Quality of recording was very good . I was curious to know if the deliberations of camera had been recorded , but ofc not lol . the part where the panel came back online to tell us their decision on the length of the award wasnt included in the recording.
I other thing was listening back to the questions and my answers again was interesting. i didnt understand or listen to the questions properly tbh ... i went off in tangents !!! my son said this to me after the hearing, but i didnt get it.
In our case the decision was based on the paper bundle not my answers i believe , but Stm of reasons will clarify that i hope.
Anyhow remember to take your time , tell the judge if you dont understand the question or ask for them to repeat it or rephrase it.
Hope thats useful.
I listened to the record of proceedings ... audio file only
Quality of recording was very good . I was curious to know if the deliberations of camera had been recorded , but ofc not lol . the part where the panel came back online to tell us their decision on the length of the award wasnt included in the recording.
I other thing was listening back to the questions and my answers again was interesting. i didnt understand or listen to the questions properly tbh ... i went off in tangents !!! my son said this to me after the hearing, but i didnt get it.
In our case the decision was based on the paper bundle not my answers i believe , but Stm of reasons will clarify that i hope.
Anyhow remember to take your time , tell the judge if you dont understand the question or ask for them to repeat it or rephrase it.
Hope thats useful.
ΣμΜ
The following user(s) said Thank You: David
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
1 month 5 days ago #315927 by Sum
ΣμΜ
Replied by Sum on topic Pip claim journey to Appeal
New PIP award letter has arrived. I was eager to see the revised scoring.
I am grateful ☺️that the tribunal awarded EDL, BUT i don't agree with the scoring.🫤 Maybe i didn't try hard enough to push for a discussion on each descriptor 🤖
When I look at the list of descriptors + associated scoring, in my view its not in line with reality and evidence supplied about the disability. I think its my neuro-brain over analysing it all.
I understand that any further points would not change the award but in my mind it would be more accurate and truthful representation of how the disability impacts life.
I'm not going to follow up or challenge.
It irks me that DWP process is not an accurate reflection of the disability. After all that what the assessment should be right ?
Sorry i just had to get it off my chest.
The scoring fiasco/discrepancies work both ways, ie to award and not award!! It really makes you wonder about the credibility of the whole process.
Thanks for listening guys
I am grateful ☺️that the tribunal awarded EDL, BUT i don't agree with the scoring.🫤 Maybe i didn't try hard enough to push for a discussion on each descriptor 🤖
When I look at the list of descriptors + associated scoring, in my view its not in line with reality and evidence supplied about the disability. I think its my neuro-brain over analysing it all.
I understand that any further points would not change the award but in my mind it would be more accurate and truthful representation of how the disability impacts life.
I'm not going to follow up or challenge.
It irks me that DWP process is not an accurate reflection of the disability. After all that what the assessment should be right ?
Sorry i just had to get it off my chest.
The scoring fiasco/discrepancies work both ways, ie to award and not award!! It really makes you wonder about the credibility of the whole process.
Thanks for listening guys
ΣμΜ
The following user(s) said Thank You: denby
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
1 month 4 days ago #315932 by BIS
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Replied by BIS on topic Pip claim journey to Appeal
Hu Sum
You were victorious. Try to let your irritation go. I don't think many people get the points allocated as they expect, and as annoying and sometimes worrying as it is, I don't think it is worth losing sleep over. If you are not happy, you can always write a letter and say that you want to put your thoughts on record - but personally, I would just make a note and use that information in the future if need be. You have worked so hard on this, and I admire your tenacity and commitment to seeing it through to the end, but for your own sake, just enjoy the victory and start to let it go (but I hope you feel better for letting off steam!)
BIS
You were victorious. Try to let your irritation go. I don't think many people get the points allocated as they expect, and as annoying and sometimes worrying as it is, I don't think it is worth losing sleep over. If you are not happy, you can always write a letter and say that you want to put your thoughts on record - but personally, I would just make a note and use that information in the future if need be. You have worked so hard on this, and I admire your tenacity and commitment to seeing it through to the end, but for your own sake, just enjoy the victory and start to let it go (but I hope you feel better for letting off steam!)
BIS
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
4 weeks 1 day ago #316021 by ANGELA
Replied by ANGELA on topic Pip claim journey to Appeal
In 16 years of applying for DLA/PIP I have only once received points that (nearly) reflect all my things. It is a completely arbitrary process, which is why it is so stressful.
Enhanced Both for 11 years (5/ 6).
Doing a review atm.
Stressed to fk I’ll get nil points. It’s bonkers.
Glad you are through to the other side, but it will take you 3 months at least to recover..
Focus on treating yourself to something nice.
Enhanced Both for 11 years (5/ 6).
Doing a review atm.
Stressed to fk I’ll get nil points. It’s bonkers.
Glad you are through to the other side, but it will take you 3 months at least to recover..
Focus on treating yourself to something nice.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.084 seconds