- Posts: 8
- Thank you received: 0
Members
PIP zero points, how much info is neccessary to include for MR?
2 days 6 hours ago #316254 by Garth
Hi - I had a PIP in-person assessment less than a fortnight ago. The morning after at around 8am I got a text telling me they'd received the assessors report. Yesterday I got the decision letter stating zero points for everything. Turns out they can do things quickly! With the timescale, it looks like it's based entirely on the assessment (which the assessor had barely read) and not on anything I submitted.
In the "my decision" section after the tables with the points score is their explanation. Three of my five diagnosed conditions aren't even mentioned here, with the two that were mentioned only in one sentence. Two of them are mental health, two neuro, and one is physical that also has an effect on mental health. Mental health isn't even referred to. Is this common in decision letters?
I'm struggling to work out what to include for the MR request. My initial application was very thorough and addressed my issues and the descriptors in detail for each condition, and covered reliability. There's not much more about them I can add in that regard, nor are there any more medical reports.
Therefore should I just include a brief challenge of the "my decision" section? My worry with that is it won't turn out brief at all as everything there contradicts my evidence and written submissions. Or is it a case of simplifying things, and stating that the report is inaccurate and it appears that my written evidence hasn't been taken into consideration?
In the "my decision" section after the tables with the points score is their explanation. Three of my five diagnosed conditions aren't even mentioned here, with the two that were mentioned only in one sentence. Two of them are mental health, two neuro, and one is physical that also has an effect on mental health. Mental health isn't even referred to. Is this common in decision letters?
I'm struggling to work out what to include for the MR request. My initial application was very thorough and addressed my issues and the descriptors in detail for each condition, and covered reliability. There's not much more about them I can add in that regard, nor are there any more medical reports.
Therefore should I just include a brief challenge of the "my decision" section? My worry with that is it won't turn out brief at all as everything there contradicts my evidence and written submissions. Or is it a case of simplifying things, and stating that the report is inaccurate and it appears that my written evidence hasn't been taken into consideration?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
1 hour 9 minutes ago #316292 by BIS
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Replied by BIS on topic PIP zero points, how much info is neccessary to include for MR?
Hi Garth
You need to ring the DWP and ask for a copy of the assessment report. It is a PA4. I would advise you to get hold of the report before you submit your MR. The report will hopefully give you more information to explain the decision. I warn you now that it doesn't always, and it may contain information that will make your blood boil, but it is easier to write your MR if you have some ideas about why they came to the decision. It is common in decision letters for information to be excluded, and you are not alone in being aghast at them leaving out key parts of your medical condition. Go through every single question and point out the evidence you gave them. Tell them what you think you should have scored for particular questions and why. You don't need to repeat everything, but if you don't explain why you think they are wrong they will simply say they stand by their decision. Don't waste time criticising the assessor, however tempting it might be - you can merely say that they are "mistaken," they "Omitted" etc.
I'm sorry this has happened. I'm not going to help with the next bit, but you need to know that less than 30% of MRs are successful. I only say that because you probably already feel as if you have been kicked in the teeth and it could happen again. Don't give up. Get hold of your PA4. They usually take 7 - 10 days to send it, though it can arrive sooner. Do not delay sending back your MR, but if it hasn't arrived in time for you to use the information inside - you contact them, tell them what has happened and say that you reserve the right to send in a proper reply. (They could ignore this, but you have to try and make a stand).
Come back, if there's anything else you need and we will try and help.
BIS
You need to ring the DWP and ask for a copy of the assessment report. It is a PA4. I would advise you to get hold of the report before you submit your MR. The report will hopefully give you more information to explain the decision. I warn you now that it doesn't always, and it may contain information that will make your blood boil, but it is easier to write your MR if you have some ideas about why they came to the decision. It is common in decision letters for information to be excluded, and you are not alone in being aghast at them leaving out key parts of your medical condition. Go through every single question and point out the evidence you gave them. Tell them what you think you should have scored for particular questions and why. You don't need to repeat everything, but if you don't explain why you think they are wrong they will simply say they stand by their decision. Don't waste time criticising the assessor, however tempting it might be - you can merely say that they are "mistaken," they "Omitted" etc.
I'm sorry this has happened. I'm not going to help with the next bit, but you need to know that less than 30% of MRs are successful. I only say that because you probably already feel as if you have been kicked in the teeth and it could happen again. Don't give up. Get hold of your PA4. They usually take 7 - 10 days to send it, though it can arrive sooner. Do not delay sending back your MR, but if it hasn't arrived in time for you to use the information inside - you contact them, tell them what has happened and say that you reserve the right to send in a proper reply. (They could ignore this, but you have to try and make a stand).
Come back, if there's anything else you need and we will try and help.
BIS
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
The following user(s) said Thank You: Garth
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.068 seconds