- Posts: 2
× Members
Good News to Encourage Others, I Hope
- KatePL2
- Topic Author
- Offline
Less More
13 years 5 months ago #59152 by KatePL2
Good News to Encourage Others, I Hope was created by KatePL2
We went to Tribunal on 28 April to appeal against a DWP decision not to give my husband ESA for a long period of sickness last year. Unfortunately it was adjourned because they had not seen a long medical report that we had submitted (it was somewhere in Cardiff they suspected!!!)
So today was Tribunal Day, and we arrived a bit early, very nervous and wondering if we could dare to hope for a good result. The Clerk told us it would be a Panel of 2.
When my husband was called in, with me accompanying, we were invited by the Judge to sit down, and he told us immediately that both he and his colleague had reached the same conclusion independently, whilst reading my husband's psychiatric report on the train. He told us that they did not propose to ask any questions, and that my husband's appeal was successful.
WHAT A RELIEF IT WAS FOR US!!!
However, I have to say that the DWP decision was fundamentally flawed - when we received it, we actually thought they had got my husband mixed up with someone else. If it hadn't been so tragic it would have been laughable.
So please, everyone who has an Appeal Tribunal coming up, don't despair - we really thought it would be so difficult and hostile, and we were wrong, thank God. If I can offer any help or support to anyone in a similar situation, please do let me know, as I know how you must feel.
So today was Tribunal Day, and we arrived a bit early, very nervous and wondering if we could dare to hope for a good result. The Clerk told us it would be a Panel of 2.
When my husband was called in, with me accompanying, we were invited by the Judge to sit down, and he told us immediately that both he and his colleague had reached the same conclusion independently, whilst reading my husband's psychiatric report on the train. He told us that they did not propose to ask any questions, and that my husband's appeal was successful.
WHAT A RELIEF IT WAS FOR US!!!
However, I have to say that the DWP decision was fundamentally flawed - when we received it, we actually thought they had got my husband mixed up with someone else. If it hadn't been so tragic it would have been laughable.
So please, everyone who has an Appeal Tribunal coming up, don't despair - we really thought it would be so difficult and hostile, and we were wrong, thank God. If I can offer any help or support to anyone in a similar situation, please do let me know, as I know how you must feel.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- cmarie510
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 237
13 years 5 months ago #59212 by cmarie510
Replied by cmarie510 on topic Re: Good News to Encourage Others, I Hope
thank you for this...
cmarie
cmarie
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Tracy A
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 53
13 years 5 months ago #59243 by Tracy A
Replied by Tracy A on topic Re:Good News to Encourage Others, I Hope
My partner has his joint ESA & DLA appeal on the 28th June, I am more worried than he is.
I cant help feeling worried due to seeing how many ill people have their appeal turned down.
My partner has had 3 heart attacks, has angina, severe sleep apneoa and also has a ICD (diffribulator)in his chest, the doc at Barts said without it he is a walking time bomb (his words).
All the medical reports are done and sent in and we are just waiting.. I hate the thought of them cross examining him and trying to trip him up, it's so unfair...
I still cant help but worry.
Thank you for your message I am glad all went well for you both.
Tracy
I cant help feeling worried due to seeing how many ill people have their appeal turned down.
My partner has had 3 heart attacks, has angina, severe sleep apneoa and also has a ICD (diffribulator)in his chest, the doc at Barts said without it he is a walking time bomb (his words).
All the medical reports are done and sent in and we are just waiting.. I hate the thought of them cross examining him and trying to trip him up, it's so unfair...
I still cant help but worry.
Thank you for your message I am glad all went well for you both.
Tracy
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- penthesili
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 296
13 years 5 months ago #59351 by penthesili
Replied by penthesili on topic Re:Good News to Encourage Others, I Hope
Best of luck to you and your partner for the tribunal hearing, Tracy. Hope you win both.
Cheers, Pen.
Cheers, Pen.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Tracy A
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 53
13 years 5 months ago #59356 by Tracy A
Replied by Tracy A on topic Re:Good News to Encourage Others, I Hope
Thanks Pen
Have two hearings one at 3pm amd one at 3.40
Will post on outcome when we get back on the 28th.
Tracy
Have two hearings one at 3pm amd one at 3.40
Will post on outcome when we get back on the 28th.
Tracy
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- justjuls
13 years 5 months ago #60210 by justjuls
Replied by justjuls on topic Re:Good News to Encourage Others, I Hope
How wonderful for you Kate, I am so pleased. You must feel like celebrating! I have been on ESA for over a year now, and still no date for my hearing, but Trib Service say within 3 months. I sent in 30 pages of evidence; but that means nothing unless you have sensible, understanding people on the panel as you had. I hope I am as fortunate....
Thanks for offering your support. We need all we can get against this 'lot'!
Juls
Thanks for offering your support. We need all we can get against this 'lot'!
Juls
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Moderators: Gordon, Gary, BIS, Catherine, Wendy, Kelly, greekqueen, peter, Katherine, Super User, Chris, David