Benefits and Work has heard from a member who says they were refused a copy of the audio recording of their PIP assessment, even though they have a legal right to it.  We want to know if this was a one-off occurrence or if it is happening more regularly.

On 29 June Benefits and Work published a news story that automatic audio recording of PIP and WCA telephone and face-to-face assessments had been introduced.  Only video assessments are exempt, apparently for technical reasons, although there’s nothing to stop you doing an audio recording yourself.

Our member says they had a PIP assessment with Capita and subsequently, on the advice of the assessor, requested a copy of the recording.

However, their request was refused “on the grounds that the recording of my assessment did not contain "security identification" details such as my name etc. and that Capita had very strict rules and would not send out such recordings.”

In fact, our member recalls that immediately after the recording started they were asked for details from their driving licence and heard the assessor typing the information into their system.

It is hard to imagine how Capita could claim that they could not establish the identity of the person in the audio recording and yet they still provided the assessment to the DWP, in order for a decision to be made.  If they didn’t know who the recording was about, how did they know who the report was about?

As our member pointed out, paragraph 1.6.63 of the PIP assessment guide stipulates that “APs [Assessment Providers] should use the audio recording solution provided by the Authority and must ensure that a copy of the recording is provided to the claimant upon request, including any reasonable requests for multiple copies.”

A Benefits and Work moderator suggested that our member make a Subject Access Request for the recording and also make an official complaint.

For the benefit of other readers, we would reiterate the advice in our guides that as well as the official recording, it is worth ensuring that you make your own recording too.

But we would be very interested to hear if any other readers have had problems getting a copy of the audio recording of their assessment and, if so, what reasons they have been given for not providing it.

Comments

Write comments...
or post as a guest
People in conversation:
Loading comment... The comment will be refreshed after 00:00.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 6 days ago
    I have had a client who has been refused his PIP assessment recording stating that ' the security checks were not carried out.' We have put in a complaint and will likely ask for a right of access request in due course 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 8 days ago
    I had a telephone based pip assessment approx 6 weeks ago. I requested a copy of the report and it was a complete work of fiction. 
    The assessor invented scenarios and conversations and it was a deliberate attempt to downgrade my score.
    I immediately lodged a complaint and asked for any decison to be paused until audio of assessment was provided. 
    I also filled a complaint with ingeus and requested a copy of the recording.  I told them it was a fraudulent report, that the audio would prove it was fiction and that I intended to report the assessor to the Hcpc as it was so serious. 
    Ingeus contacted me to claim they had an error with the telephony system and no audio recording was available.
    They are acting like a law unto themselves and it's clearly systemic with dwp. 
    It was mandated that all telephone pip assessment should be recorded.  This was mandated due to assessors previously acting fraudulently. That they are ignoring this mandated requirement speaks of the arrogance of them and how they treat claimants
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 9 days ago
    I have recently been denied a copy of my WCA recording for the reason their "security checks were not completed on the call". I know they did the security checks at the beginning of the call as I and my partner remember.  I submitted a DSAR to Ingeus almost immediately for this assessment call and decision process (as they rejected my application for WCA or LCWRA having made some glaring errors). They called me in response to the DSAR and took it as a complaint regarding the recording request.  They told me they will be doing an investigation which will take a maximum of 20 working days.  It's appalling to read that other people have experienced the same. It makes me very sceptical.  I am also expecting to end up at a Tribunal but I really need the recording for proof of the discussion that took place, or rather the questions that were not asked but still lead to a decision with no empirical basis!
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 9 days ago
    I have had both an ESA work capability assessment and a PIP assessment by phone. (September 2025 and November 2025). 
    On both occasions I stated clearly in advance that I wanted the session recorded and that I wanted a copy sent straight away because I was too ill to be able to make my own recording. Both interviews were with Serco. The ESA one was conducted by a doctor with experience of ME!  I received my recordings on a CD after a couple of weeks both times. 
    On my forms I had put that I was receiving help from Citizens Advice and that I needed recordings for them in the event of any dispute about my award. Maybe this focused some minds on doing it properly, or maybe I was just lucky to get Serco assessors. 
    I was put in the support group for ESA by the doctor but only got standard care and mobility for PIP, which CitA said was ridiculous, but I couldn't face fighting the DWP with my energy levels. I'd already delayed claiming PIP because the stress of ESA WCA and the PIP form together was too much for me. 
    I've since had the PIP award extension to 4 years before review. 
    The fact that you're too sick to go through the process even with help is quite common. 
    Anyway I thought I'd better let you know a positive experience and I'm extremely glad I didn't get Capita. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 13 days ago
    I requested that my PIP medical assessment was recorded. Serco did not want to do this, and did their best to dissuade me; telling me I could record the assessment myself, and that the appointment would have to be delayed and rescheduled for later as they apparently need longer than 9 days notice to arrange an audio recording of an assessment! I held out, and said that I wanted the assessment recorded. On the day of the assessment, when I received the phone call from my assessor, I checked that the assessment was going to be recorded. I was then told that there was a problem with the recording equipment and that if I wanted to have my assessment recorded, I would have to wait. I asked how long? The assessor didn't know, she said she would get back to me, and put the phone down. So I was left, on the day of my assessment, very stressed, not knowing whether the assessment was going ahead or not, or even whether I was going to get a phone call back or not. Eventually I did get an assessment done, over an hour late, by a completely different assessor who they claimed had access to recording facilities. The phone line was terrible and I had to keep asking for the assessor to repeat questions. She said several times that the sound issues were because of the recording. Only afterwards did I realise that the assessor had not begun the assessment by reading a statement saying that the assessment was being recorded: that is supposed to happen I believe.
    When the medical report was released, I phoned Serco to obtain my copy of the recording. The person I talked to on the phone said that I had to wait a certain number of days before the recording would be sent to me - I had phoned just a couple of days before this so they were unable to chase up the recording for me. I therefore waited until the requisite number of days were up, and phoned back. The person I talked to the second time was a lot less polite. They told me that I should not have been told that, the recording would be sent out when it was ready. Mine had not been sent yet - they had a backlog. End of conversation. I phoned again after another couple of weeks, but again I was met with rudeness just for wanting a copy of my own medical assessment recording. By this time I had already had to submit my PIP Mandatory Reconsideration and Appeal. It seemed pointless to continue banging my head against a brick wall: they clearly weren't giving me that recording. Fortunately, I had made my own recording using a dictaphone; it was clear enough for me to hear the discrepancies between what I had said and what was recorded in the medical report, and to realise there were important points that had been missed out of the medical report altogether, even though in general, it wasn't a bad assessment or report. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 13 days ago
    I requested my PIP assesment was recorded last October 2025 and I just can not believe they still lied and  twisted everything i said. 13 major untrue statements taking me from Enhanced daily living and Enhanced mobility to absolutely zero and taken off PIP completely.  12 months and im still waiting for tribunal. How they think they can possibly get away with all them lies when it's recorded well I have no idea . That was the whole point in it recorded.  I thought it would obviously stop the lies and having to go through all the stress of appealing and tribunal. UNBELIEVABLE. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 14 days ago
    I had requested a recording of my telephone reassessment & the 1st booked appointment was cancelled on the day & they rebooked it for 3 days later,
    Many weeks later I requested a copy of the call & was informed that it wasn’t requested for the rebooked appointment but it was for the original booked appointment,
    I argued that my original request should of been carried over to the next booking as I wasn’t the one who rebooked the appointment,
    On a good note I was awarded the enhanced rate for both parts & No review for 10yrs which made up for the initial disappointment & the only reason I requested a recording my 1st assessment mentioned some wording in the report that I disputed .
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 14 days ago
    I had a PIP assessment on 15th June this year.  I telephoned Capita that morning, as advised in my appointment letter, and asked for my assessment to be recorded.  When I got to the assessment centre and told the receptionist that I had requested a recording I was told that they knew nothing about this.  I was advised to speak to my assessor when I went through to her office for my assessment.  I did this and she also claimed she had not been told about my request.  She even had to get the receptionist to help her set up the recording.  I had to sign to say that I was happy with the recording taking place.  She set up her phone to record and assured me that all was well.  At the start of July I telephoned Capita to ask when I might receive my recording.  I was told that I had to request a copy, which would be on a cd.  I thought this was rather odd, considering that I had asked for the assessment to be recorded and expected that they would take it for granted that I wanted a copy of it!  So the request was not put in until that day, 1st July.  I was advised that there was a backlog in sending out the recordings (quelle surprise!) and that I should phone back again in a couple of weeks.  I phoned 2 weeks later but was again told that it had not yet been sent out (I have lost my notes about this phone call so cannot state any more details).  I phoned again on 22nd July and was told there was still a backlog.  I phoned again on 11th August to chase delivery of the cd recording.  I was told that it would not be a cd that I was sent, it would be a link to the recording!  I told the advisor that this was contrary to what I had been previously told.  She said it was the DWP that sent out cds, not Capita (?!).  She said she was add a note to my file and put through a request to send the link for the recording within 14 working days.  I never received the link.  Instead I was eventually telephoned (I have lost my note as to when this was) about the assessment recording.  The advisor told me he had been working through the requests for recordings (just him alone!) and when he listened to mine it had not recorded properly.  All there was on the recording was static and therefore he apologetically said that a recording could not be provided.  I was very annoyed about this, as you can imagine!  Due to all of this delay and then disappointment regarding the recording, I had requested an extension to the time allowed for me to supply a completed CRMR1 form (stating why I disagreed with the decision to refuse PIP).  I was given a 2-week extension and told to request a further one if necessary, though provision of this could not be guaranteed.  Again I was given the runaround on this, with the last piece of advice being that there really wasn't a set date for me to return the completed form and that they are each looked at in turn, notes on each file are read and if the form and any extra evidence had not been received, then the case would be put aside for a bit longer.  He confirmed that my MR would not be "written off" and that someone would telephone me if they read an update.  I would point out that as well as my MR, I was also dealing with another, very stressful situation at the time and, due to being AuDHD (diagnosed autistic [AS] over 9 years ago, self-diagnosed ADHD quite recently) I procrastinated on completing the CRMR1 form, thinking that due to the advice I had been given during my last phone call to request a further extension, I was still okay.  It transpired that, yet again, I had been given incorrect information.  No-one telephoned me to enquire why I had not yet sent in the completed CRMR1 form and any further evidence and on 14th September I received a decision on my MR, stating that PIP could not be awarded to me.  I was very angry that this had happened and immediately began to complete the online request to take my case to tribunal.  Eventually, after having trouble logging on the the online gateway to finish completing my tribunal request, I gave the whole situation further thought and decided not to pursue my PIP claim.  It was all getting too much and affecting my mental health.  Having had to go to tribunal to secure an ESA award and finding that extremely stressful (luckily I was successful though), I just couldn't face more months of waiting and more stress.  


  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 14 days ago
    I had a phone PIP re-assessment and had already asked for a recording as my original assessment was so biased that I had to take them to a tribunal which I won.
    I was told the reassessment was being recorded and confirmed my agreement. I was then led on a wild goose chase between Capita and the DWP each saying it wasn’t theirs to give- after many phone calls I gave up I’m afraid.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 23 days ago
    I've just had a pip telephone assessment last week and I recorded this myself i told the lady I was recording it .
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 23 days ago
    It’s just getting a work capability assessment at the moment which is the problem i have been waiting 16 months now for a uc lcw-lcwra worsening health conditions I think this time might get it with depression anxiety adhd autism and syncope(blackouts)all documented on nhs medical records would prefer a telephone but if it’s face to face then my mum will record it on her phone and will let other readers know next year how it went in the meantime I don’t have a work coach because they have all given up so am being left alone for now 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 22 days ago
      @James h @ James H I'm glad you're not being pestered by the work coach at least that's something positive whilst you wait.

      Let us know how you get on. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 22 days ago
      @Jonno Jonno thanks yes I filled out a new uc50 in may last year before that dwp only had depression as main condition I don’t have lots of evidence but i do have what is needed incase I get a disaster and have to go to a tribunal but I keep on hoping will post next year here whenever I get seen and obviously the possibility of backpay keeps me going and at least the journal has been quiet touch wood 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 23 days ago
      @James h @James h. That's a ridiculous length of time to wait for a medical due to change of circumstances.

      Did they ask you to fill in a new UC50? 

      Hope you get your WCA soon and you get awarded LCWRA. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 23 days ago
    When I requested a recording a few years ago they simply didn't send it, then they claimed to have lost it, then to have already sent it. They eventually sent me a cd recording half the length of the assessment and refused any further correspondence on the matter

PIP & The WCA Are Changing- Get The Latest News

Stay updated with our free, fortnightly newsletter.

Over 140,000 claimant and professional subscribers.

 
iContact