A rift has opened between two Timms Review steering group members over suggestions that disability living allowance (DLA) for children should be radically cut. 

Last month we revealed that Jean-André Prager, a member of the Timms Review steering group, was the co-author of a report calling for extreme cuts to child DLA for mental health, learning difficulties and neurodevelopmental conditions.  The report was published by his employer, the right-wing Policy Exchange thinktank.

Last week, however, Disability Action Haringey (DAH) published a rebuttal to that report.  Phil Stevens, DAH’s chief executive is also a Timms Review steering group member and, according to Disability News Service, co-wrote the response to Prager’s report.

The DAH document argues that “Removing financial support does not remove a child’s disability long term health condition, additional care and supervision requirements, transport needs or the disabling barriers they encounter. Costs may instead move onto families, education, health services, social care, local authorities, appeals and tribunals, or voluntary and community organisations.”

It goes on to point out that “Additional caring responsibilities can restrict a parent carer’s capacity for paid employment and therefore have direct financial consequences for the household.”

And its conclusion is that “Disabled children should not be required to surrender individual financial security in order to fund public services that should already be accessible to them. Reform should start with evidence about children’s needs and the barriers they face, not with a predetermined savings figure and an eligibility system designed to deliver it.”

Although the Timms Review concerns PIP rather than child DLA, the disagreement raises questions about its members’ wider approach to disability benefits.

Which view commands more support on the Timms Review steering group: drastic cuts to disability benefits or financial security for disabled people?

Comments

Write comments...
or post as a guest
People in conversation:
Loading comment... The comment will be refreshed after 00:00.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 15 days ago
    Sad to see that once again that many on this forum have a "As long as the reforms don't affect my age demographic that's all that matters.." attitude. The government will inevitably continue to squeeze money from the welfare state tighter and tighter regardless of your age, once they are done with tightening the eligability criteria of the teens/20s they will come for the 30s, then the 40s, then the 50s, etc.. They will especially push forward with it if we as a sick/disabled community just sit back and allow one age demographic to be victimized just because it's not our age range! Sad to see some quite selfish viewpoints to be honest. Someone in their 20s who is debilitatingly sick/disabled is JUST as worthy of financial support as someone in their 60s. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 13 days ago
      @Dpb999
      A kinder interpretation might be that some very frightened folks are just trying to find out how they're likely to be impacted (given the worrying storm of speculation, especially around age groups), not that they're thinking

      'it's fine if 'the reforms don't affect my age demographic that's all that matters'.

      I see no reason to believe there's a 'do it to Julia' (1984 reference) attitude on this forum towards anyone in their 20s who's sick or disabled.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 14 days ago
      @Dpb999 Alas!
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 14 days ago
      @Dpb999 Totally agree with you.  Divided we fall.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 16 days ago
    https://www.mirror.co.uk/money/dwp-update-new-jobs-passport-37843886

    Many of the jobs/employers listed here are some of the most stressful (esp if you have a condition like autism - speak from experience), low paid, fast paced jobs with bosses that lack understanding.

    Hospitality/retail is probably one of the worst suited job fields for many varieties of disabilities and health conditions.

    Instead of the gov underwriting wages and forcing neets to work for stingy, big corp names who will abuse the situation like the furlough scheme (these companies can afford to pay these neets wages out of their own pocket - waste of money that the gov will be footing the wages) they should be listing an ad for freelancers and small businesses across all fields and offering underwriting wages there instead - the neet is more likely to get one to one help/training and much less chaotic and overwhelming then the big fast foods chain.

    But yes, force neets into positions that they will never earn much more than minimum wage and will probably repel them off the idea of employment for god.

    You will never get neets or disabled into work if it makes you question the point of life.


    The government is right when they say work is good for your health - but only if you enjoy what you are doing and aren’t working in a hostile environment (once again hospitality and retail are one of the worst sectors in terms of caring about a employee wellbeing- again personal experience)

    Politicans once again ignoring the obvious!
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 15 days ago
      @D I can vouch for retail: back in 2017!I did the Christmas period at Tesco. I hated it, the management were poor (I complained to the CEO) and they were only willing to pay for 15 hours, this avoiding paying employer National Insurance. Totally exploitative. The other atea I can disabled youngsters been pushed into is call centre work...where you'll need a very thick skin dealing with abusive customers.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 16 days ago
    And what about those over 25? Say 50 plus ( I'm 53 and I know I keep saying it but is it surprising that U do considering that this while thing could absolutely destroy people like us?
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 14 days ago
      @Wibblum Can't help it I'm ruddy scared stiff and this is one of the only places that has a sensible approach to it all 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 15 days ago
      @N.B.C Neil Labour won't do anything with the over 50s until after the next election if at all can't you look on the bright side.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 16 days ago
      @N.B.C The fact that the gov is going to underwrite wages for jobs for neets suggests the gov is aware that there’s not enough jobs to go around.

      This neet project sounds like a huge undertaking so I’m not sure they’ll be many additional resources for the over 25s (the closer a person is to the state pension the less taxes that person will bring in via taxes.

      I think the focus on 26-68 yr olds will be tightening pip criteria - I don’t think the dwp will have the resources to support these ages into work as well as this neets strategy.

      The older you are the less likely the gov will think you are a priority in terms of getting to work and reducing welfare

      Even the gov has said it’s a mountain to climb with a claimant that hasn’t worked for 20 years (the 40-50 awkward age group) 

      Prehaps we’ll get lucky and the dwp will count their losses with pre existing over 40 disabled claimants - of course pigs could also fly as well!)
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 16 days ago
    The Milburn review final report has been handed over to the DWP.

    According to the media it recommends 16-24 NEETS who are disabled or have a chronic illness. Get intensive skills training. Are guaranteed employment. Can choose flexi-jobs to set their own working hours to suit their capabilities. Can choose job carving, where what would be a job for one person can be split into multiple jobs for multiple people so people capable of doing some of the work can be employed. But, no statutory quota for employing disabled people, instead it relies on employers voluntarily signing up to the scheme as employing young disabled workers will be subsidised by the government, topping up their wages, making them cheaper to employ. The various costs will be funded by benefits savings.

    It sounds nice but unfortunately it looks possible that UC health element LCWRA, LCW might be abolished for those under 25 and replaced with the help. When the current test to get those elements is being incapable of even an imagined ideal suitable part time job, the type of job the recommendation wants to create more of. And being incapable of even an imagined suitable type of help or training to make the person more employable, the type of help and training the recommendations want to create more of. So how do they become capable of doing those things when they are made real if they cannot even be imagined to be capable of that. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 14 days ago
      @JBob1234 Milburn's recommendations are heavily based on the Dutch system.

      The Dutch system uses carrot and stick for both employers and disabled people.

      In the Dutch system the carrot for employers is subsidizing disabled workers wages so they are cheap to employ. Milburn recommends this. And in the Dutch system the carrot for the disabled is work paying more than not working and being just on benefits. Milburn also recommends this but the government looks likely to increase this financial motivation by removing UC health for under 25s. That turns the carrot into a stick as it becomes work or be in severe poverty.

      In the Dutch system the stick for employers is the threat of government imposed job quotas for the disabled and fines if they fails to meet their quota. Milburn going by the media reports does not recommend this. Not doing so will in my opinion cause the system to not create and maintain the number of jobs needed. In the Dutch system the stick for the disabled is the threat of benefit reductions if they fail to take up offered appropriate training and employment. Milburn recommends this and the media reports it as they need tough love. Given how low UK benefits already are especially if they are not going to eligible for UC health, it is very tough love, it is basically the threat of destitution.

      Despite the talk in the report of it not being disabled people's fault. As actions speak louder than words using benefit cuts and benefit sanctions to motivate the disabled, and no stick to motivate employers. Creates the impression disabled people are primarily to blame, and are choosing a life of idleness on overly generous benefits. As cutting benefits and increased conditionality and benefit sanctions is the imposed solution.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 15 days ago
      @JBob1234 Milburn review is also expected to recommend local authorities adopt proactive outreach where youth workers engage directly with young people in their own neighbourhoods. Literally knocking on their doors an engaging with NEETS rather than leaving them alone and abandoned by the state to a life of idleness and benefits.

      Sounds nice but what about those for whom engagement is likely to be detrimental to health. With the plan to abolish the WCA how will they be identified and safeguarded, so they do not literally get youth workers knocking on their door.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 16 days ago
      @JBob1234 So, question is, has the Milburn review factored in that an understanding of Schrodinger's cat would be required in order to deliver the training?
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 16 days ago
      @JBob1234 Love that last paragraph, @JBob1234, you've surpassed yourself there! 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 17 days ago
    With a child who has ASD along with other physical medical conditions DLA was a real help until the age of 18 The thought that our child had not got that support is hard to think about As our extra costs with bringing up our youngest child would have got less or even no DLA at all Would have brought hardships for or family 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 18 days ago
    https://inews.co.uk/news/hidden-crackdown-pip-benefit-assessments-get-tougher-4866954

    I hope those journalists and MPs that have made it their recent mission to smear disabled welfare claimants on a daily basis are forced to read this reality and Prehaps shelve their fictional theoretic’s for a week or 2
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 17 days ago
      @D
      "“The pressure is to reduce [points]. You can see the back and forth [between manager and assessor] multiple times in a case."

      It would be interesting to know which type of cases this is happening in. Given the sustained propaganda about "mild mental health conditions", it wouldn't be surprising if that is mostly where assessors are being pressured to reduce points. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 17 days ago
      @bronc From the independent article posted above:

      >Securing disability benefits is getting harder for new applicants as assessors take a tougher approach

      >The proportion of successful new claims for personal independence payments, known as PIP, has been steadily declining since April 2024, analysis of official Government figures shows.

      >Experts and insiders told The i Paper the downward trend is due to “harsher” assessments and that decisions were increasingly going against applicants.

      > The UK’s budget watchdog has revised down forecasted spending on working-age disability benefits by £1bn for 2030-31, although the wider welfare bill will still grow overall.

      > 
      > The proportion of new PIP claims resulting in an award after an assessment has decreased from 48 per cent to 42 per cent when compared to last year. Analysis by The i Paper shows a steady decline in success rate since April 2024, when 54 per cent of new PIP claims were granted.

      > 
      “The pressure is to reduce [points]. You can see the back and forth [between manager and assessor] multiple times in a case. It’s happening more often – you can see it in tribunal cases.”
      Assessors have also become less flexible when it comes to judging fluctuating conditions, such as multiple sclerosis (MS) or the chronic pain disorder fibromyalgia, Merrell added.

      > 
      “Assessors seems to be saying, ‘They’re working, therefore they can’t possibly be as ill as they say’,” Thomas said.

      > 

    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 17 days ago
      @D Seems to be behind a paywall. What does it say? Presumably they haven't changed the qualifying criteria as that would need legislation.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 17 days ago
      @D please can you summarise what it says as it is behind a paywall, thanks
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 18 days ago
    Absolute bstds. How dare they go after kids. 🤬🤬🤬
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 19 days ago
    I wish they would understand that a disability is costly not just because it can bring up additional costs, but that many of us simply cannot juggle a disability, full-time employment and running a home. Something has to give and we can't get rid of our disability, the benefits are certainly not enough to hire a cleaner/ care-taker, so the employment has to take a step back. Should we be forced into a life of poverty for circumstances beyond our control?
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 18 days ago
      @asmith25 Hi all, I suspect I'm going to have to give up full time work. I was rushed to ICU last week with DKA, a blood infection and now advised I needed an injection to avoid a blood clot ...I eventually found trying to run a very inaccessible flat, plus going to work and managing insulin injections is just too much.
       
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 19 days ago
      @Marc Exactly and well said! I consider most of my extra costs arising from being autistic to come from not being able to maintain a job without burnout. It's something that can't be easily measured but the cost is very real. In truth, these costs would be reduced if workplaces and the wider world were accessible in the first place.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 19 days ago
    If you are the type of person who want to take money from children, how can we possibly expect them to care about adults? Why is he even on this panel?
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 19 days ago
      @Aw Because they had to get as many privileged right wing tory disabled people in as they could so they could say they co-produced and listened to disabled people, but making sure it supported the blue (not) labour political choices, agenda and ideology.  These people were chosen to be on the panel for a reason.

PIP & The WCA Are Changing- Get The Latest News

Stay updated with our free, fortnightly newsletter.

Over 140,000 claimant and professional subscribers.

 
iContact