A survey for the More in Common non-profit organisation has found that the majority of the public do not support the proposed cuts to personal independence payment (PIP) and believe cost cutting, not getting people back into work, is the main reason for welfare reform.

According to the poll, only 31% of Britons feel that the Government is trying to limit the impact of cuts on vulnerable groups, while 20% think that it is not trying, and 36% think that the Government has actively chosen to target certain vulnerable groups.

54% believe that the cuts to benefits are about saving money with only 32% considering that they are about getting people back into work.

44% of all Britons think that welfare reforms are too harsh, 28% think they are about right and only 10% think they are too soft.  If Labour hope that their welfare cuts will play especially well with Reform voters, they might be disappointed to learn that 41% of Reform voters think they are too harsh, compared to 42% of Labour voters.

When asked about specific PIP descriptors, the public disagree with Labour’s 4 point system.

74% of Britons believe that needing assistance to wash below the waist should automatically qualify someone for disability-related benefits; 72% say the same about needing help to dress their lower body; 70% say the same about needing assistance to get out of the bath or shower.

None of these are 4 point descriptors, so none of them would allow access to the daily living component of PIP.

43% of Britons think that the benefits cuts make Labour appear mean-spirited.

34% of Britons say they know someone on disability benefits and 36% of people who know someone say the proposed reforms have decreased their trust in the Labour Party to manage public finances safely, 36% say it has made no difference and only 15% say the reforms have increased their trust.

Even amongst all Britons, not just those who know a claimant, 30% say the reforms have decreased their trust and only 15% say they have increased their trust.

So, it would seem that in spite of all the bile and hatred below the line on many media websites, the public are less than enthusiastic about benefits cuts - especially for disabled claimants.

You can see a detailed breakdown of the More in Common survey here.

Comments

Write comments...
or post as a guest
People in conversation:
Loading comment... The comment will be refreshed after 00:00.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 10 hours ago
    For us disabled it's not that we don't want to work we really do it's that we can't. It's hard enough & now lots of disabled people will die or become homeless due to these cuts. It's inhumane. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 16 hours ago
    I've a spinal injury, fibromyalgia, osteoarthritis, neuralgia, neuropathy, TMD, asthma, extensive Raynauds, anxiety, depression and other issues that combine to make my life nothing more than an existence. I scored a 3 in one of the descriptors and thought i should've got more in a number of the areas but it took them nearly a year to complete my soft review so I was just relieved I got my award again and couldn't cope with even more stress of appealling the decision. It's exhausting – especially if you're on your own trying to do it and battling your conditions. Removing my pip isn't going to remove my health issues and force me into work, it'll just make me destitute and no longer want to exist... Or maybe that's the plan... 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 11 hours ago
      @Lifeless27 That's exactly how i feel. I have fibromyalgia & lots of other issues & I've just been awarded the higher rate. Losing £450 a month if this goes ahead which i will then need to sell my house which Is adapted and need a disabled council property which puts more strain on there finances. It's honestly made me feel so down & we feel bad enough with the suffering we already endure all day everyday. It makes me want to end it all. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 17 hours ago
    You took my pip away well over a year ago and I'm still waiting to go to tribunal.   my condition continues to get worse, my jobs in jeopardy if I don't get some help soon. If I lose my job because of my condition I will then be more of a burden on the state. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 3 hours ago
      @Riddled with anxiety! 😭 Terrible situation for you, the system is cruel.  One thing you could do in addition to what you have already done.  Write a letter to the DWP and the tribunal. Briefly list any contradictions, factual errors,questions they have not replied to. Then say something like "I am too ill to argue these points at a tribunal, but please can I respectfully ask the judge to look at the above points and tell me if I have been treated lawfully".
      It worked for me, worth a go.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 11 hours ago
      @Riddled with anxiety! 😭 These cuts are just going to make it worse & more people claiming benefits in another way & it's going to kill people. The system is already awful. I hope you get your pip sorted soon. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 17 hours ago
    Utterly cruel.  I might score 3 points in all categories but no 4...so that means that  my osteoarthritis, my ME, my chronic pain, my anxiety, my shoulders with torn tendons have all improved so much I no longer require any support!  How can you decide I'm better by rearranging the numbers 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 17 hours ago
    The 4 point descriptor is shocking, I have ms and don’t score 4 on the care component, if an employer would employ me I would need to ask for help with my clothing to use the toilet, how humiliating, it’s bad enough asking for help from my husband, I don’t think this proposal has been thought out properly, we are just an easy target 😢
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 18 hours ago
    The DWP at the moment can not keep up with renewals, MR’s and tribunals now so the back log if this green paper gets approved is going to be a nightmare for them, they will not cope with all the appeals after with new and old claims. Even now if you have already have a descriptor with 4 points, they will just reduce it to a 2/3.
    I’m helping my brother who lives alone was awarded enhanced for mobility but nothing for daily,  sent in so much evidence that they still declined so now going to tribunal.  He has early onset dementia because hes had epilepsy for 40 years and his medication has effected his brain so it is shrinking, he has absent seizures daily so he can not use an over or hob, just microwave ready meals.  I have to put his medication into pill boxes because he doesn’t remember if he has or hasn’t taken it.  Medical appointments I have to be with him because he doesn’t understand or remember what’s happening.  I do his shopping etc.  we’ve been waiting nearly a year so far for tribunal and monthly I’m sending in letters from the doctors.  Still waiting for an appointment with memory clinic.  His neurologist has told me it will only get worse.  During this last year he has rapidly gone downhill.  I’ve asked them to come and see him but no.  He’s living off his savings (which was for when he retired but has years to go) are depleting with only £300 mobility coming in.  The boat people get treated better than him.  So CHANCELLOR, would you please  tell me how you’d get him back into work!!!!!!!
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 18 hours ago
    The government keeps making this about young people or people who don't work and helping them get jobs but this is about taking support from people with physical disabilities who have already been treated very badly by a system aimed against them.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 11 hours ago
      @Andrew How are pensioners like myself going to deal with this? Do they want us to work too? Or more likely kill us off and save on pensions, the cost of which they complain about so much. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 21 hours ago
    I do not understand where this government are coming from by saying that people on PIP can go back to work after losing there entitlement. They seem to have forgotten that PIP is paid to people if they work or not. I am waiting to see if my PIP will carry on after having to apply last November when my review date is not until July. I'm 66 in September so will fingers crossed get my state pension then so will lose my ESA and it's legacy benefits. I try not to think what will happen if I don't get the award this time around as I'm not well enough to take it to tribunal. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 21 hours ago
    I am retired 74 year old on light touch every 10 years. I can’t remember my descriptors score yet nothing is being discussed about us. We can’t work to make up for the loss and it’s a very great loss if it’s suddenly taken away. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 2 hours ago
      @Andy Coyne Susie here and I totally agree with you. I am 74 too a lady veteran. As  you say nothing mentioned about us yet. Just like you on 10 year light touch  so nothing I have will improve with age worse luck. I think just have to hope for the best now
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 21 hours ago
    It isn't long ago that Westminster was found to be treating the poor, elderly, sick and disabled very badly. (Special Reporter?). Nothing has improved. Now it's about to get even worse. I USED to be a card carrying member of Labour. Now I see no hope.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 22 hours ago
    My wife scored 2 points for each descriptor, so a total of 20 points. Under the current proposals she will lose the care component, even though her scores show she has a broad overall need, rather than focused on a couple of areas.
    There were areas we could have argued that 2 was too low a score, but didn't, as she had the full award. Looks like more hoops to jump through next time around ..
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 23 hours ago
    My first claim for pip went on my medical records and an  phone call I wrote told them things have got worse sent more evidence they turned me down for help to get around I have survier osteoarthritis in my spine and hips my needs have changed iam 64 cannot do the job no more I was doing iam going into retirement with disabilities I personally think there fingers are stuck on two points permently for almost every care need I don't no anyone that has scored 4 points I would love to sit at  there desk and go throu points system they use it badly needs updated ive asked for reconsideration falling this i will prepare for an appeal fight them all way it disgraceful what they put disabled people throu to get help they need. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 11 hours ago
      @Jacqueline MacFadyen When I got to tribunal, 20 months after applying, they would not consider my more recent prescribed wheelchair. I lost our adapted van, and life crumbled from the on, can't even get a blue badge now. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 20 hours ago
      @Alison Before you get to appeal process, ask your GP for your updated medical records from when you applied for PIP and send these to the appeal panel. You have much the same issues as me. I won my appeal because I am on high doses of tramadol which make me sleep most of the day and would be too dangerous for me to work. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 22 hours ago
      @Alison Totally agree. I have had 2 total hip replacements and osteoarthritis in both knees.I get the basic daily living payment but I can wash my upper body so there will be hundreds and hundreds in this position. I need assistance to wash and dry my lower limbs so what difference does being able to wash ,dry my upper body without help but need help to do my lower body.Its absolutely bonkers.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 23 hours ago
    What makes me so cross about all of this is that PIP is not a means tested benefit. It’s not based on being able to work or not it’s based on support for your individual needs when you’re chronically ill, that result in needing extra support in order to live independently. It doesn’t make a difference to the employment sector if you are able to work or not whilst receiving PIP, and yet by insinuating that if you don’t get PIP you can just go back to work is not only wrong but it’s damaging for the mental and physical health of those who are unable to work because their illness affects them so badly that they can’t work. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 23 hours ago
    If you can’t wash or dress below the waist you cannot care for incontinence needs without support, and you cannot care for your feet or the skin on your legs without support. This is essential if you are also diabetic. This is my situation. I pray that they change the scoring on this descriptor as at present I score only 2s all related to physical problems. I am chair based and can only walk a few steps. I have to employ a foot care assistant, buy incontinence supplies, someone to change my sheets and clean my house because I can’t , do more washing  and showering than a non disabled person, replace or repair my assistance and mobility equipment, and that is just so I can live a clean and hygienic life at home. I was awarded PIP (standard living and higher mobility) two years before I reached retirement age and and I got a 10 year award. I know my award can’t be increased and I know that I’m likely to lose my living component.  It’s going to have such an impact on my quality of life. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 11 hours ago
      @Poppkins I have many of these problems too and very similar needs. I have high rate care and low rate mobility. No 4’s. It’s very debilitating and completely unfairly scored. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 1 days ago
    "Starmer criticises watchdog's benefits forecasts" Just saw this pop up on BBC



    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 15 hours ago
      @Anniesmum The derogatory and dehumanising language labour have been using towards the sick and disabled is shocking too :(
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 15 hours ago
      @Anon I know – especially when the tories tried to cut benefits and labour attacked them for it. What gets me it's the statistics they quoted for fraud etc were wrong which they were called out for but never apologised. All is doing is putting a bigger target on the back of disabled and sick people – as if we don't feel bad enough as it is :(
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 23 hours ago
      @keepingitreal Worst government on record.

      14 years of Tory rule was better than this.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 1 days ago
      @Pixelmum He also spoke in a way that made me think he believes disabled people can change their behaviour if they are taken off benefits. The OBR doesn’t take this behavioural change into account. Almost implying that disabled people chose to be disabled. Check out this video https://youtu.be/eoBjHzMc-qc?si=WLUBU_IYUSIoHZgH
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 1 days ago
      @Pixelmum Labour side-lining the OBR already after introducing law to prevent future governments from doing that 🙄
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 1 days ago
    Not quite sure where I should post this but I have an important update that may give others hope. I had to complete my PIP review in August as it was up for end of award in March 2025. Quite tough because lve spent 9 months ( amidst all the speculation and proposed changes) worrying but trying not to. I was convinced l would be down graded in Daily Living.
    Today came the decision: l scored 16 in Daily Living including 4 in two categories and 12 in mobility.
    I obviously don’t know what might happen to people with different conditions but l am trying to send some calming love. I have Lupus (which is of course a serious condition) Polymyalgia Rheumtica. I also have an unhealed broken hip which needs two operations.
    Never the less there are people worse off than me. Don’t lose hope 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 16 hours ago
      @Cmjdexter I to have just had my latest review completed and was given a 4 point descriptor It was given to me for the first time Along with an ongoing claim  I was so worried until the letter arrived With all the turmoil and uncertainty about PIP swirling around I am glad about my review But worried for others 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 18 hours ago
      @Cmjdexter Quite an achievement without having to go for a dreaded assessment with someone clueless and unqualified. You did well.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 1 days ago
      @WorkshyLayabout Purely paper based and no assessment at all. Because l get ulcer type lesions and rashes, l can provide pictures and l think that helps. It doesn’t mean l am more disabled than someone who has invisible needs, but it means that l have visual evidence 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 1 days ago
      @Cmjdexter Did you have to go for an assessment or was the decision based purely on the paper form?
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 2 days ago
    Just heard on the BBC news that the government values the millions of unpaid carers in this country, is that why they are going to take away our carers allowance if the person who we are caring for loses their pip because of the proposed changes if they come in?
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 3 days ago
    The people of this country vote for a welfare system and employ MP's, at considerable cost, to administrate the public purse, all of it, correctly distributed to the services we deem it necessary to be credited.
    This is Government for the people, by the people, a democracy functioning properly. 
    Twenty-seven Labour MP'S have grasped the nettle, carrying out the specific tasks they were elected to perform. Pathetic, except for the twenty-seven. 
    Strange policies brought by whimsical MP'S not voted for by the people, are a gross dereliction of duty. 
    This is the tail wagging the dog, an accountable offence, bordering on a dictatorial executive, like the last government! 
    Really, YOU the people, are their employer, so do your employer's duty, s
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 3 days ago
    WorkshyLayabout re Bob's situation, he would likely not be considered fit for work, unless he was judged to have recovered after a new wca assessment which he could challenge, especially if he has fit notes. Lcw would be his category, with minimal claimant commitment and engagement with a work coach, therefore he would not be left with nothing. His risk of sanctions reducing his award is also very low, since work related activity does not demand being a job seeker.

    Whilst all claimants of incapacity and disability benefits are likely to lose some part of their award, I feel you are mistaken in the more extreme of your fears and confused in your evaluation of the impact of the proposals on those over state pension age.


    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 1 days ago
      @keepingitreal As Bob fails to qualify for PIP, he is no longer entitled to either health element of UC and deemed fit to work. The only benefit he can now claim is the jobseeker's allowance equivalent of UC. His risk of sanction reducing his award is high, since jobseeker's allowance demands being a jobseeker. Sanctions leave him with no money. 

      Pensioners who lose PIP will continue to get state pension (and pension credit for those not getting a full state pension). They will not be left with no income. Bob is not a pensioner. He will be hit harder should his PIP entitlement be removed.

      This is the true impact of the proposed changes. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 4 days ago
    This government who allegedly are the grandchildren of the people who originally started the labour movement have for the most part transformed into a party of political opportunities and a carer due to their privileged lifestyles and education and do not see things the way the original founders of the labour movement did. There is a need for a new movement that will revive the original ideals that have been abandoned in a new movement that will prevent this sort of nepotism to happen that will end up destroying the very principles it started out with.
We use cookies

We use cookies on our website. Some of them are essential for the operation of the site, while others help us to improve this site and the user experience (tracking cookies). You can decide for yourself whether you want to allow cookies or not. Please note that if you reject them, you may not be able to use all the functionalities of the site.