- Posts: 17
- Forum
- Members forums
- ESA, PIP and DLA Queries and Results
- Tribunal application - Which benefit do I select?
× Members
Tribunal application - Which benefit do I select?
- Enigma123
- Topic Author
- Offline
Less More
1 year 4 months ago #281031 by Enigma123
Tribunal application - Which benefit do I select? was created by Enigma123
Hi,
I'm not sure if anyone will have a definite answer to this, and i've not seen it mentioned anywhere through google searches. Having now got to the point where, due to my WCA, and follow up mandatory reconsideration the DWP believe I am "ok to work", I want to have things go to a tribunal. My WCA though (unbeknown to me at the time as the form I filled out was the ESA50) was a dual one, which has affected both my UC, and my cbESA. I've been told that the cbESA has now stopped (no letters, only verbally by the decision maker). My UC, I was told I will still get, but of course only at the basic rate, and I now don't know what will be expected of me from the work coach while I wait for the tribunal. So I don't know which benefit I should have selected when applying for the tribunal (and you can only pick one) - i've gone ahead and selected UC, as when I did the MR, the address on the letter was for UC. I'm worried i've done the wrong thing though - my wife thinks I may have, as only ESA has actually been completely stopped. I've spent half the day on the phone trying to get through to the HM Courts and Tribunals hotline, but eventually gave in. Same story with the CAB. I'm sure I can't be the only person who's been in this position though, as anyone who claims both ESA and UC who fails the WCA must be in the same position? It seems unfair to me that the DWP use one WCA to affect two benefits, but I can only complain about one or the other, is this just another one of their tactics to make things so unbelievably complicated that you'll give in?
I'm not sure if anyone will have a definite answer to this, and i've not seen it mentioned anywhere through google searches. Having now got to the point where, due to my WCA, and follow up mandatory reconsideration the DWP believe I am "ok to work", I want to have things go to a tribunal. My WCA though (unbeknown to me at the time as the form I filled out was the ESA50) was a dual one, which has affected both my UC, and my cbESA. I've been told that the cbESA has now stopped (no letters, only verbally by the decision maker). My UC, I was told I will still get, but of course only at the basic rate, and I now don't know what will be expected of me from the work coach while I wait for the tribunal. So I don't know which benefit I should have selected when applying for the tribunal (and you can only pick one) - i've gone ahead and selected UC, as when I did the MR, the address on the letter was for UC. I'm worried i've done the wrong thing though - my wife thinks I may have, as only ESA has actually been completely stopped. I've spent half the day on the phone trying to get through to the HM Courts and Tribunals hotline, but eventually gave in. Same story with the CAB. I'm sure I can't be the only person who's been in this position though, as anyone who claims both ESA and UC who fails the WCA must be in the same position? It seems unfair to me that the DWP use one WCA to affect two benefits, but I can only complain about one or the other, is this just another one of their tactics to make things so unbelievably complicated that you'll give in?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Gary
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 8169
1 year 4 months ago #281053 by Gary
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Replied by Gary on topic Tribunal application - Which benefit do I select?
Hi Enigma123
I am a bit lost with your post, ESA now called "legacy ESA" is no longer available to new claims except in very special circumstances.
The difference is that legacy ESA was one benefit consisting of two eligibility criteria, one based on the claimant's NI Contribution history (Contribution Based ESA) and the other on their personal circumstances (Income Related ESA).
New Style ESA only considers the claimant's NI Contributions, the equivalent to ESA(IR) is Universal Credit.
From your post, tell me if I am wrong, I believe that you have had a Work Capability Assessment (WCA) which you failed and have applied for a mandatory reconsideration (MR) which you have also failed and now you want to appeal.
I don't understand what you mean ESA50 was a duel one which affected your UC and CB ESA.
I think what may have happened and I can only guess, is that you received LCWRA in your UC claim which stopped when you failed the WCA, this would have closed your CB ESA and reduced your UC.
You do need to seek advice from your local Welfare Rights Organisation who will be abe to take all your circumstances into consideration; you can find your local Welfare Rights Organisation to help you with advice by clicking on the link below and putting in your post code, it will then come up with a MAP with a list of agencies. advicelocal.uk
Gary
I am a bit lost with your post, ESA now called "legacy ESA" is no longer available to new claims except in very special circumstances.
The difference is that legacy ESA was one benefit consisting of two eligibility criteria, one based on the claimant's NI Contribution history (Contribution Based ESA) and the other on their personal circumstances (Income Related ESA).
New Style ESA only considers the claimant's NI Contributions, the equivalent to ESA(IR) is Universal Credit.
From your post, tell me if I am wrong, I believe that you have had a Work Capability Assessment (WCA) which you failed and have applied for a mandatory reconsideration (MR) which you have also failed and now you want to appeal.
I don't understand what you mean ESA50 was a duel one which affected your UC and CB ESA.
I think what may have happened and I can only guess, is that you received LCWRA in your UC claim which stopped when you failed the WCA, this would have closed your CB ESA and reduced your UC.
You do need to seek advice from your local Welfare Rights Organisation who will be abe to take all your circumstances into consideration; you can find your local Welfare Rights Organisation to help you with advice by clicking on the link below and putting in your post code, it will then come up with a MAP with a list of agencies. advicelocal.uk
Gary
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Enigma123
- Topic Author
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 17
1 year 4 months ago #281082 by Enigma123
Replied by Enigma123 on topic Tribunal application - Which benefit do I select?
Hi Gary,
It was contributions based ESA I was receiving (cbESA) that has now stopped. I originally applied for both that, and UC at the same time, at the advice of the Citizens Advice Bureau - I think it was purely so i'd receive some payment every 2 weeks (cbESA). I was on the basic assessment rate for both benefits, and was waiting for the next stages to happen (WCA's). I received an ESA50 form in the post, so assumed this was leading to just an assessment on the cbESA, and that at some point i'd receive another for my UC. I didn't realise they'd use the one WCA to make a decision on both benefits. The result of me being found "ok to work" meant the cbESA ended, and the UC didn't, but obviously the UC payments won't be going up, and i'm assuming now my claimant commitments will change for the worse (i'll find out Monday as I have my phone, work coach appointment). Obviously, I now want to appeal. The MR also went against me, so next move is a tribunal. When I asked for the MR, I wasn't sure which benefit i was asking to be reconsidered (as both were affected by the decision) - I left a note on my journal, and eventually I had a message saying "write both benefits on the form" which I did. Doing the online tribunal application though, you don't get that option - you can only select one. So i've selected UC. I know there's no additional money to be had by receiving both benefits (as UC subtract any cbESA from the UC payment), but at the same time, I do dispute the decision made against both benefits.
My real concern now, is that when I have my work coach call on Monday, rather than what has been discussed on previous calls, "Are you doing your physio? Are you keeping up with your meds?", i've got a feeling i'll now be told my commitments have changed, and I have to immediately start looking for work or be sanctioned. Even though I need to spend most of my time sat in my recliner chair to try and avoid being in pain, i'll have to either agree to the new commitment, or have my benefits stopped. I won't in reality be actually able to do any form of work due to my condition, but i'll have to agree to try, and end up putting myself at risk of possible serious injury or have my claim ended. Doesn't seem right to me.
It was contributions based ESA I was receiving (cbESA) that has now stopped. I originally applied for both that, and UC at the same time, at the advice of the Citizens Advice Bureau - I think it was purely so i'd receive some payment every 2 weeks (cbESA). I was on the basic assessment rate for both benefits, and was waiting for the next stages to happen (WCA's). I received an ESA50 form in the post, so assumed this was leading to just an assessment on the cbESA, and that at some point i'd receive another for my UC. I didn't realise they'd use the one WCA to make a decision on both benefits. The result of me being found "ok to work" meant the cbESA ended, and the UC didn't, but obviously the UC payments won't be going up, and i'm assuming now my claimant commitments will change for the worse (i'll find out Monday as I have my phone, work coach appointment). Obviously, I now want to appeal. The MR also went against me, so next move is a tribunal. When I asked for the MR, I wasn't sure which benefit i was asking to be reconsidered (as both were affected by the decision) - I left a note on my journal, and eventually I had a message saying "write both benefits on the form" which I did. Doing the online tribunal application though, you don't get that option - you can only select one. So i've selected UC. I know there's no additional money to be had by receiving both benefits (as UC subtract any cbESA from the UC payment), but at the same time, I do dispute the decision made against both benefits.
My real concern now, is that when I have my work coach call on Monday, rather than what has been discussed on previous calls, "Are you doing your physio? Are you keeping up with your meds?", i've got a feeling i'll now be told my commitments have changed, and I have to immediately start looking for work or be sanctioned. Even though I need to spend most of my time sat in my recliner chair to try and avoid being in pain, i'll have to either agree to the new commitment, or have my benefits stopped. I won't in reality be actually able to do any form of work due to my condition, but i'll have to agree to try, and end up putting myself at risk of possible serious injury or have my claim ended. Doesn't seem right to me.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Gary
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 8169
1 year 4 months ago #281089 by Gary
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Replied by Gary on topic Tribunal application - Which benefit do I select?
Hi Enigma123
Thank you for explaining yourself.
You initially applied for NS ESA which is contribution based on your national insurance payments, this usually lasts for one year unless you are placed in the support group in which case your claim is indefinite until you are next reassessed.
As you rightly stated NS ESA is paid fortnightly, you can at the same time as applying for NS ESA also apply for UC especially if you need help with housing costs.
As you failed the WCA your NS ESA would have ceased leaving your UC claim in place, you applied for a MR, this also failed and now you are applying for an appeal. You are appealing against a Work Capability Assessment, have you contacted DWP and asked for a copy of the assessors report called a UC85? you need this report to base your appeal on any inaccuracies within it.
As for the claimant commitment;
There are 4 conditionality groups:
* Group 1. No work related requirements
* Group 2. Work-focused interview requirement
* Group 3. Work preparation requirement
* Group 4. All work-related requirements
www.entitledto.co.uk/help/Claimant-commitment-Universal-Credit
You will need to come to an agreement with your workcoach as to which group to place you in, also inform them you are appealing the decision, I would also ask your Dr for a fit note to help, but quite often Dr's are sent a letter asking them not to issue a fit note.
Gary
Thank you for explaining yourself.
You initially applied for NS ESA which is contribution based on your national insurance payments, this usually lasts for one year unless you are placed in the support group in which case your claim is indefinite until you are next reassessed.
As you rightly stated NS ESA is paid fortnightly, you can at the same time as applying for NS ESA also apply for UC especially if you need help with housing costs.
As you failed the WCA your NS ESA would have ceased leaving your UC claim in place, you applied for a MR, this also failed and now you are applying for an appeal. You are appealing against a Work Capability Assessment, have you contacted DWP and asked for a copy of the assessors report called a UC85? you need this report to base your appeal on any inaccuracies within it.
As for the claimant commitment;
There are 4 conditionality groups:
* Group 1. No work related requirements
* Group 2. Work-focused interview requirement
* Group 3. Work preparation requirement
* Group 4. All work-related requirements
www.entitledto.co.uk/help/Claimant-commitment-Universal-Credit
You will need to come to an agreement with your workcoach as to which group to place you in, also inform them you are appealing the decision, I would also ask your Dr for a fit note to help, but quite often Dr's are sent a letter asking them not to issue a fit note.
Gary
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Enigma123
- Topic Author
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 17
1 year 1 month ago #283641 by Enigma123
Replied by Enigma123 on topic Tribunal application - Which benefit do I select?
Hello everyone,
Just thought i should update you all on the upcoming tribunal I had, to dispute the WCA decision (and mandatory reconsideration) of "ok to work". The DWP were late responding to the courts, and were given an extension to reply. About a week before that 2nd deadline, I had a call to tell me that they'd looked at my case again, they were not going to dispute things in court, and they had reconsidered things, this time, in my favour. Not only that, but they put me in the LCWRA group. Not long after that, I had letters from the DWP regarding the cbESA that was stopped, and I was put back on that, in the support group.
So moral of the story - don't give up if you know they've made a wrong decision on your case. The day I was informed, my bank account was near empty - i've now had all sorts of back pay put in, and there's more money in there now than i've had in a long while!
Just thought i should update you all on the upcoming tribunal I had, to dispute the WCA decision (and mandatory reconsideration) of "ok to work". The DWP were late responding to the courts, and were given an extension to reply. About a week before that 2nd deadline, I had a call to tell me that they'd looked at my case again, they were not going to dispute things in court, and they had reconsidered things, this time, in my favour. Not only that, but they put me in the LCWRA group. Not long after that, I had letters from the DWP regarding the cbESA that was stopped, and I was put back on that, in the support group.
So moral of the story - don't give up if you know they've made a wrong decision on your case. The day I was informed, my bank account was near empty - i've now had all sorts of back pay put in, and there's more money in there now than i've had in a long while!
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- BIS
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 8275
1 year 1 month ago #283644 by BIS
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Replied by BIS on topic Tribunal application - Which benefit do I select?
Hi Enigma123
Many congratulations on winning your case. That is so good to hear. So glad you have your bank payment and can enjoy the feeling of having some money again.
BIS
Tags: @RESULT @ESA
Many congratulations on winning your case. That is so good to hear. So glad you have your bank payment and can enjoy the feeling of having some money again.
BIS
Tags: @RESULT @ESA
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Moderators: Gordon, Gary, BIS, Catherine, Wendy, Kelly, greekqueen, peter, Katherine, Super User, Chris, David