The Tribunals Service has launched a consultation aimed at cutting the cost of disability tribunals and reducing the growing backlog of cases, by allowing them to be heard by a judge sitting alone, rather than a panel of three members. The changes would affect PIP, DLA and AA appeals and could result in worse outcomes due to a lack of understanding of medical and disability issues. PIP tribunals, for example, currently have a success rate of 67% for claimants and it would be a disaster if this last line of defence was weakened.
The issue was highlighted by a Benefits and Work member who is also a disability qualified tribunal member posting in the forum. We will let our member speak for themselves and we would urge readers to respond to a consultation which will otherwise attract very few submissions.
Our member’s post
The Tribunal Service is currently reviewing various aspects of tribunal arrangements, including who sits on panels hearing PIP, DLA and Attendance Allowance appeals. At present, these hearings are normally heard by a three-person panel:
- A Judge, who applies the relevant legislation and legal tests.
- A Medical Member, who brings medical knowledge and expertise in understanding conditions and their potential effects.
- A Disability Qualified Tribunal Member (DQT), who brings knowledge and experience of disability and how it affects people’s everyday functioning. This may come from personal experience of disability, caring responsibilities, or professional experience supporting disabled people.
There is a possibility that panels could be reduced to a Judge sitting alone, or that decisions about whether additional panel members are required could be made based on the papers before the hearing.
As a DQT myself, I am concerned about the potential consequences of this.
The three roles bring different, complementary expertise to the decision-making process.
The Judge is essential in applying the law correctly, but the legal tests are necessarily very specific.
The Medical Member brings an understanding of medical conditions, their effects and the complexities that can arise when someone has multiple conditions.
The DQT role is particularly important in understanding how someone’s conditions actually affect their day-to-day functioning. Two people with the same diagnosis can have very different experiences. Conditions can fluctuate, vary considerably in severity, and interact with one another in ways that aren’t always obvious from medical evidence alone.
Claimants are often stressed, overwhelmed or simply unaware of what information is relevant to their claim. They may not fully explain the difficulties they experience, either on their forms or during the DWP assessment process. Part of our role is to identify those gaps, ask the right questions and explore difficulties that might otherwise go unnoticed.
My concern isn’t that Judges sitting alone would be unfair, or that they wouldn’t apply the law correctly. Rather, it’s that removing the additional expertise from the panel could mean that important functional difficulties aren’t identified or fully explored, potentially resulting in claimants not receiving the awards they are legally entitled to.
I’m also concerned about the possibility of deciding whether a full panel is necessary based solely on the papers. Cases that initially appear straightforward can turn out to be some of the most complex once a claimant’s difficulties are properly explored. It isn’t always possible to identify that complexity from paperwork alone.
If specialist panel members are removed, or only included when a Judge considers them necessary based on the papers, there is a real risk that difficulties which aren’t immediately obvious, or which claimants struggle to articulate themselves, may go unexplored.
I would strongly encourage anyone affected by these benefits, or concerned about the fairness of the appeals process, to read the consultation and respond themselves.
You don’t need to be a legal expert or have any professional knowledge of tribunals to participate; your own experiences and views are just as valid and important.
What you can do
You can read the details of the consultation here.
The consultation form is here.
You don’t need to give your name and you don’t need to answer every question, just the ones that are relevant to you. Particularly important is question 2:
“Are there particular types of case, issues or areas of expertise for which the involvement of Tribunal Members is essential? Please explain why.”
If you have personal experience of an appeal hearing and the medical or disability member helped the tribunal make a fair decision, this would be especially useful evidence. For example, For example, did either member ask a question that helped you explain a difficulty the panel might otherwise have missed?
Confusingly, the Judiciary gives two different closing dates, one in its announcement and a different one in its downloadable document. To be on the safe side, send your response before Monday 25 January 2027