The government will set out its response to the Timms and Milburn reviews before the end of this year, with a White Paper being published early in 2027 followed by legislation later that year,  Chancellor John Healey announced in his budget speech today.  Other measures of importance to claimants include a £100 household energy payment, relief from energy debts for some and the abolition of gas standing charges.

The rapid timetable for PIP changes suggests that Labour is anxious to be seen to be doing something about welfare reform.

However, it should be noted that enacting legislation in 2027 does not mean that major changes to PIP will actually be put in place the same year.  Given that it is taking the DWP over three years just to change the calculation software for carer’s allowance, sweeping changes to PIP may not be in place prior to the next election.

Keep up with the Timms review

Subscribe to our free newsletter to get all the latest Timms review news.

The Household Energy Payment will provide a £100 payment to households in Council Tax bands A to D in England from January 2027, to help with their energy costs.  Households in England are eligible for the Household Energy Payment if they are liable for council tax on, and live in, a property in council tax bands A to D as their main home.  

This will include most households exempt from council tax, with full eligibility criteria to be published in due course. 

The Energy Debt Relief scheme means that if you are the energy billpayer and you are on means-tested benefits, disability benefits, or are a pensioner, and you have built up debt since the energy crisis of 2022-4, you may be eligible to have your debt written off through the Debt Relief Scheme, provided you take steps to re-engage with paying your debt.

Standing charges on household gas bills will be removed in 2027, or as soon as possible afterwards, with the cost being transferred to the unit price of gas. Low to average users of gas will benefit from this move.  However, it may mean higher bills for people who have to use a large amount of gas because, for example, their health condition means they need to keep warm.  The government say there will be “targeted mitigation for some households”.

 Some other welfare benefits measures detailed in the budget had already been announced, such as ending the carer’s allowance cliff edge, changes to Motability  and cracking down on fraud.

The budget document also claims that Labour are “Committed to stopping claims management companies from charging to help people to claim benefits” although so far the only action taken seems to be social media and other adverts advising people that they should not pay to claim attendance allowance.

In all, there was little in the way of change in this budget that most readers did not already know about.  The most important news for claimants is due next month, with the publication of the final reports by the Milburn and Timms reviews.

Comments

Write comments...
or post as a guest
People in conversation:
Loading comment... The comment will be refreshed after 00:00.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 19 days ago
    To me, the fact that the upcoming PIP reforms need a primary legislation proves that major changes are on their way, and not simply a tweaked PIP, which would not necessarily require any legislation.

    As the African saying goes, "When two elephants fight, it is the grass that suffers", not only have benefit claimants become the grass of political parties trying to find fault with one another, but also the famous "the sacrificial lamb."
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 19 days ago
    What's the changes to the mobility sceme can't find anything just wondering as I have a car 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 19 days ago
      @Wayne Hi Wayne, the two main things are that some so called "luxury" cars have been taken off the scheme, and all new leases are limited to 10,000 miles a year. If you exceed 30,000 by the end of a three year lease you will be charged a mileage rate for the excess.

      "Luxury" cars is pure politics, as the whole of Motability is NOT paid for by taxpayers, and to get a more expensive car a customer has to pay thousands in non returnable down payment.

       There is some hidden disability discrimination in these limits, as some people need a big car simply because of their disability. Eg my OH simply cannot physically sit in a small cheap car because he has a leg that has had to be surgically fixed with no bend. [And we had to pay extra for altered seat runners for him]. Very many people need a big car to be able to carry a wheelchair etc. Some people cannot avoid high mileage due to frequent and or long distance medical appointments, living in a rural area. Etc.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 19 days ago
      @Wayne The budget speech "We’re reforming Motability" was just referencing already announced changes. No new changes to the Motability scheme were announced.

      On Motability the budget documents just say "The government has already acted: Reforming Motability, with tax breaks restricted to save over £1 billion over the next five years, and Motability Operations removing luxury vehicles from the scheme"
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 20 days ago
    Burnham wants to avoid being called benefits Burnham so has chosen to give £100 to band A to D homes regardless of household income, rather than using the same money to provide more help to fewer households via targeting UC and pension credit households.

    Getting rid of the standing charges and increasing the unit cost of gas is expected to result in a small drop in bills for those who use less than 12,000 kWh and a slight increase for those that use more.

    As someone who lives in a band E home and uses more than 12,000 kWh of gas a year I am unimpressed. Especially compared to the extra help Sunak gave households towards their energy bills.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 15 days ago
      @cloudcuckoo
      Thanks for the correction on home care costs. 


      It is not a matter of me just wanting to asset strip people. It is a matter me wanting people to be treated the same. Look at it the reverse way.

      What is wrong with treating rental income from lodgers the same for everyone on means tested benefits. Instead of a homeowner on UC (all lodger rental income ignored), a renter on UC (all lodger income ignored but they are subject to the underoccupancy penalty), a homeowner on pension credit (50% of rental income over £20 counted as income). What makes the pensioner on pension credit less deserving of keeping their lodger rental income? And what makes other income sources including earned income less deserved for those on UC?

      What is wrong with treating capital the same for everyone on means tested benefits. Instead of accessible excessive pension pot money ignored, accessible overpayments in a mortgage account in effect equity in their home disregarded, excessive savings in a current account counted. What makes the person with £6,250 in their current account less deserving of keeping their savings than someone with hundreds of thousands in a pension pot or someone with tens of thousands of accessible overpayments in a mortgage account?

      What is wrong with wanting excessive pension pots made accessible as a minimum income source in hard times, and paying those people less or no means tested benefits. If the money was in any other form of investment it would be counted, and they would receive less or no means tested benefits. Again what makes someone with £6,250 in a current account less deserving than someone with hundreds of thousands in a pension pot.

      What is wrong with having UC treat money obtained from a pension pot the same for everyone. Instead of ad hoc payments (treated as capital regardless of what the money is spent on or how many ad hoc payments are taken), annuity or regular fixed interval payments (treated as income). What makes the person taking an annuity or regular fixed interval payments less deserving of support?

      What is wrong with treating housing excessive to need the same for everyone on means tested benefits. Own the home (ignored), paying a mortgage (not eligible for SMI if the home excessive to need, so are in effect forced to sell the home downsize and live off the extra equity they had in the home), come into money while on benefits (buying an excessive to need home deemed deprivation of capital and forced to sell it and buy a home that is not excessive), renting (under occupation penalty), and as the excessive home is also an investment any other form of investment (counted as capital). Also being a home owner does not mean no extra cost to the state. Home owners can get council tax reduction, and grants for home maintenance and home improvements. What makes those with a mortgage or renting or those on benefits who come into some money or those with other investments less deserving of support.

      Note I also disagree with you on your interpretation of what the DWP count as deprivation of capital. As far as I know the DWP does not care what people with less than £6,000 in savings spend their savings on. The DWP does not require all claimants on means tested benefits to account for their spending and save up and acquire savings so they no longer qualify for benefits or get less benefits, and if they fail to do so lose their benefits because they spent rather than saved. The DWP as far as I know only cares what people who already have or had £16,000+ or £6,000+ savings spend that money on, as spending that money gives them eligibility to benefits or more benefits.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 17 days ago
      @JBob1234 @JBob1234 Care home charges are not capped at £86,000 and there are no time limits on local authority care assessments, so any spending over a lifetime has to be justified or it can be counted as deprivation of capital for the purposes of avoiding care home fees. Burnham's plan for free social care does not extend to residential homes.

      Social housing tenants below state pension age are assessed as underoccupying even if they let any 'spare' rooms, so still have to pay bedroom tax, which limits what they can earn from the extra space.

      Even if money from lodgers is disregarded by uc, disposing of the income extravagantly rather than saving it could be treated as deprivation of capital.for the purpose of retaining means tested benefits.

      Similarly, even ad hoc pension withdrawals are not free of scrutiny and there are many pitfalls to accessing a pension in that way. Regular drawdown and annuity payments, including notional annuity income, are taxed/means tested and included in care home financial assessments.

      The restriction on how much can be left to close family free of inheritance tax ensures that where the inheritance is divided between several beneficiaries there is some provision for younger family members to reach an otherwise unattainable step on the property ladder, reducing overcrowding and freeing spaces on social housing waiting lists. Older beneficiaries with health or care needs get some respite from the assessment system and are less of a drain on public resources. Not all beneficiaries of modest estates deriving from family homes are unduly enriched by the efforts of their ancestors.

      If your own circumstances make you feel unfairly advantaged that is between you and your conscience. You are free to make charitable donations, but it seems to me you have already been, and are still 'doing your bit', paying down your mortgage and pension, looking after your brother and keeping us all informed!

      They mostly get you in the end, anyway, JBob, but I don't see the value in asset stripping people who have done their best to provide for themselves and their families, paying tax and staying out of the welfare system. There are exceptions, as I have acknowledged, but mostly, as far as welfare goes, those who can pay are paying (I'm not talking about super wealthy tax avoiders).

      There are many schemes and social tariffs which make a substantial difference for all means tested benefit claimants, including for those in receipt of uc, who you seem to believe are hard done by. I rather agree with you on the £100 give away - unnecessary tinkering for the better off and much more is needed for those on low incomes, although substantial grants have been available for heating oil for some time and are ongoing. Perhaps the blanket bonus will ease the resentment felt towards welfare claimants in general, and we could all do with that.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 17 days ago
      @cloudcuckoo As far as my opinions being born out of the politics of envy. I am on UC and have a home excessive to need and now I am 55+ have a pension pot I can access and if I out live my brother I could rent out spare bedrooms if I wanted to. So it is not envy.

      It is a sense of unfairness.

      It is looking at the reality others on UC face of poverty, material deprivation, reliance on food banks, and inability to afford to heat their homes and eat healthy in winter. And their fear of welfare cuts that could see them destitute.

      And seeing their capital and income treated differently. Their capital over £6,000 resulting in reduction of benefits, their unearned income being deducted penny for penny from their benefits. And knowing if while on benefits they came into money they would be deemed to have to be deliberately depriving themselves of capital to claim benefits if they bought a home excessive to need and stuck an excessive amount of money into a pension pot.

      It just stinks to me of one rule for the poor another for the comfortably well off. So even if the comfortably well off fall on hard times they get better protection via excessive housing and excessive pension pots including accessible pension pots, and lodger income all being disregarded. And to that list I will add the ability to make payments from benefit income into a pension pot and gain an extra 20% from tax relief on tax you have not paid, so your benefit money savings are in effect more than for someone unable to do so as well as not being counted as capital.

      And the same applies to working people getting in work UC. Who in addition to the above can due to children and housing costs and pension contributions get UC even with earned incomes far higher than average.

      There is no politician and media cry of reduce the max household income from earnings and unearned income and capital gains, people can have and still claim UC. No cry of count ad hoc pension pot lump sum money by default as income spread over the following 12 months so it is treated the same as an annuity or regular pension payments. No cry of have a £20 cap and 50% taper for lodger income so UC treats lodger income the same as pension credit does. No call for massive welfare reform by making excessive pension pot money accessible regardless of age as a minimum income in hard times and giving those people reduced or no means tested benefits. No call for massive welfare reform by expect people who can move to move out of their excessive homes or make some of their benefits a loan secured on their home payable on death or home sale.

      Instead the politicians and media scapegoat and demonize the poorest on benefits especially the ill and disabled unable to work. As living lives of idle luxury subsidized by the tax payer. And the cuts are to their benefits.


      As far as homes excessive to need being hit if someone needs to go in to a care home. Not everyone ends up in a care home, care home charges are capped at £86,000 then people can get state help, and the government is planning on creating free social care for the old.

      As far as inheritance tax goes, thresholds enables a surviving spouse to leave up to £1,000,000 (due to the family home allowance and inheriting their spouses allowance) tax free to their children. And if the Tories get into power they plan to abolish inheritance tax.

      There is also nothing stopping people from realizing the capital in their excessive home via downsizing and/or home equity release when they reach state pension age. Especially as they may no longer be on means tested benefits. As once someone reaches state pension age, pension pots are no longer disregarded. And pension credit lodger income is treated far less generously than under UC.

      Letting out part of their home maybe providing a service and helping people. But it is not being done for free. If I out live my brother I have three spare rooms that is easily over £2,200 a month rental income from lodgers that would be disregarded by UC. When any other source of unearned income would be deducted penny for penny. And any source of earned income has a cap and a taper. I just don't think that is fair.

      Drawing from a pension pot is not always subject to means testing in a applicable way. As I previously pointed out ad hoc lump sums are in my opinion a loophole.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 17 days ago
      @JBob1234 @JBob1234 That's a bit of an instruction manual right there for how to 'circumvent the system', as you put it!

      There are always going to be winners and losers, and always those who find different ways to exploit the rules.

      I'm not sure hanging onto an 'excessive to need home' is such exploitation. If the occupants have to go into care their home is included in the means test. If they down size and spend the capital they wont contribute to those care costs but wont be able to claim benefits until they run out of money, and their home will be gone. If they stay in their big old mansion and leave it to beneficiaries their estate could be liable for inheritance tax and they might well have had to pay huge maintenance and running costs on that home.

      Letting out part of their home provides a service and helps people hold on to their assets until they can no longer live independently. Building equity in a home or saving into a pension could be seen as admirable thrift in comparison to spending all your disposable income on a high life.

      Drawing from a private pension, in whatever manner, before or after state pension age, is subject to means testing in the applicable way and also to taxation. After state pension age an untouched private pension is subject to a notional income calculation and, if it remains unaccessed, can be added to a care home financial assessment or taxed at any beneficiaries' marginal rate.

      Individuals are always able to calculate what would be the least damaging way for them to manage their finances, but in the end most people with means cannot avoid contributing to their own upkeep. Forcing folks out of a cherished and hard earned family home just seems mean and spiteful, borne of the politics of envy. Any choice involves a trade off.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 18 days ago
      @cloudcuckoo Below are some of the reasons I think the means testing system is broken. As some people have their wealth and income ignored while others do not, including in some cases the same assets or income sources. And I think it could be made fairer. And if the government wants to cut welfare spending it is something I think they should have looked at.

      Pension Credit rules I believe are different to UC on rental income from lodgers. UC ignores all the rental income. That in my opinion is unfair as any other unearned income is deducted from UC, and any earned income has a cap and taper.

      Anyone on means tested benefits is subject to means testing on any capital they have if the capital is not in their home. Excluding the home is fair in my opinion if the home is not excessive to need. If it is excessive to need it is not fair in my opinion. An excessive to need home should not be exempt for some and not for others. As if acquired while on benefits or expecting to end up on benefits it would be counted under deprivation of capital. For example someone on benefits receiving an inheritance who used the money to buy a home excessive to need would not be eligible for benefits.

      As far as detrimental effect to health if forced to move that currently applies only for eligibility to SMI not UC. You can be perfectly able to sell up and move and instead get to stay in your excessive to need home and claim UC. And as mentioned above can rent out any spare bedrooms and have all the rental income disregarded by UC.

      Anyone on means tested benefits has accessible savings counted as capital unless it is in an overpaid mortgage account in effect equity in their home, or a in a pension pot and they are under state pension age. That is unfair as someone with a traditional mortgage account and a current account has their current account counted, but anyone with overpayments or equity in a mortgage account they can access does not have that counted. I think it is also unfair in regards to large pension pots as if someone is on benefits or expects to be on benefits puts excessive money into a pension pot it might be counted as deprivation of capital. The government should in my opinion count all excessive pension pots and change the law to make the excessive money accessible at any age as a minimum income if the person would otherwise be eligible for means tested benefits.

      Anyone accessing a pension pot at age 55-66 has the money accessed counted as income unless they are are accessing it via a ad-hoc lump sum in which case the individual ad-hoc lump sum is treated as capital not as income. They can take multiple ad hoc lump sums as often as they like as long as their capital never goes over £6,000, so can access money spend money accessed money spend money. But if they accessed their pension as an annuity or set regular payments say once a week or once a month it would count as income. I think that is also unfair. The government should in my opinion count ad-hoc lump sums as if they are spread over the following 12 months as income unless the claimant can prove the money was used for a one off cost like a home repair, or to pay off debts not acquired to circumvent the system.

      Talking of debts. Paying off debt (excluding unenforceable debt to friends and family) is never counted as deprivation of capital by UC. That is unfair as someone who knows they are coming into money appears to be able to deliberately spend the money however they please before they get it. While someone who gets the money and has their benefits stopped or reduced is required to spend the money on living expenses or things that are deemed reasonable by the DWP, as money spent otherwise can be deemed deprivation of capital to claim benefits.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 20 days ago
    Still feeling very anxious over this Timms review, this Gov refused Starmers proposed cuts, will they go for Burnhams cuts when they come out? Burnham seems to be trying to soften the blow. But thT Timms review feels like an anti-disabled manifesto.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 19 days ago
      @tintack If government tries and force pip cuts they will meet with the same response to the last time. I know a lot of disability agencies that have not been consulted about the times report. Let's see what it says when it gets published. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 19 days ago
      @Marc
      If the Timms review is met with widespread opposition from those who stand to be on the receiving end of it, the government is going to have a major problem, even if it successfully gaslights its own MPs into believing that it was a genuine co-production. It is going to be very awkward indeed if the very people who were supposedly going to be shaping the proposals respond to the review by making it clear that it does not have their support. 

      We know how things went for Starmer when he tried to make PIP cuts: it proved to be the beginning of the end for him. If it's clear that the Timms review proposals would screw over sick and disabled people, and we make it clear to Labour MPs that we know that, then Burnham will also have a major problem on his hands, no matter how much he flutters his eyelashes.

PIP & The WCA Are Changing- Get The Latest News

Stay updated with our free, fortnightly newsletter.

Over 140,000 claimant and professional subscribers.

 
iContact