The initial response to the Milburn review by backbench MPs seems to have been largely positive.  But so far they have only heard one side of the argument and it’s now up to disabled people and their supporters to highlight the shocking reality of how Milburn’s proposals would affect young disabled claimants and their carers.

We’ve set out some of the issues below, though we are sure readers can think of more – please share them in the comments below. 

Choose the matters that concern you the most or that you have personal experience of and contact your MP, All Party Parliamentary Groups, members of the House of Lords, disability organisations and others about them.  Find out more about how to contact all these groups here.

We’d suggest keeping your responses fairly short and rooted in your own experiences and beliefs.  We suspect long tracts written using AI are less likely to be read.

And please do share what you write or the responses you get below, to encourage other readers and to help us spot the official party lines as MPs begin to use them.

Who will lose out, and by how much?
Milburn estimates that the proposals would save £3.6 billion in welfare spending in 2036/37. The analytical annex confirms that the modelling included current and future claimants. But the published figures don’t tell us how many people would lose out, how much they would lose on average or which conditions would be most affected. Why hasn’t the DWP published a breakdown? Milburn report, paragraph 789, and analytical annex.

What happens to people already on PIP or UC health?
Milburn proposes reassessing existing claimants for the new benefits. Their current payments would continue during the transition, but what happens after that?

At 2026/27 rates, someone on the higher UC health element and both standard rates of PIP could lose around £893 a month if they were moved onto the basic Youth Allowance alone. Someone on the higher UC health element and both enhanced rates of PIP could lose around £1,273 a month. Either would be extraordinarily difficult to adjust to. Will existing claimants get any protection against a sudden drop in income after reassessment, and what did the DWP assume about that protection when it calculated the savings?

How will carers qualify for Carer’s Allowance?
Either rate of the daily living component of PIP can currently help someone qualify for carer’s allowance. If PIP is replaced for under-25s, which awards would count and how would carers already receiving the benefit be protected?

If they are not protected, some households could be left to deal with the effects of losing both PIP and carer’s allowance.  Again, the modelling for the £3.6 billion benefits savings must have taken into account the effect on the number of carer’s allowance awards, but the report keeps the information secret.

Will young people still be able to use the Motability scheme?
The enhanced mobility rate of PIP is one route into the Motability Scheme. What would replace it, and could someone who depends on a Motability vehicle to get to work, college or medical appointments lose it when they move to the new system?

Could vulnerable young people lose their homes?
What would a drop in income mean for a young person in supported accommodation who has to cover service charges and other living costs? This matters especially for care leavers and young people who can’t safely move back in with family.

What if you can’t afford to pay for the help you need?
If your family helps you for free, or you go without taxis, equipment or paid support because you can’t afford them, you may have little evidence of the actual cost of your disability. How would the Additional Cost Allowance assessment take account of what it would cost to meet those needs?

Could benefit cuts make young people’s mental health worse?
The Fonagy review agreed with the findings of a separate review, that “increases in individual or household income improved mental health and wellbeing, while decreases worsened them”.  What Milburn is proposing could lead to a potentially dramatic decrease in the income of some households that include a young person with mental health issues.

Substantial risk — what replaces the current safeguard?
The report doesn’t address the existing substantial risk rule. What protection would you have if being required to prepare for work could seriously harm your health, but you didn’t qualify for Severe and Complex Needs Insurance? DWP figures released in May show that there are tens of thousands of young claimants currently assessed as having limited capability for work-related activity by the DWP who could be harmed by these proposals, yet Milburn does not mention them once in his final report. 

And he responded with anger and obscene language when the Disability News Service challenged him  about his failure to discuss the safeguarding risks involved in forcing tens of thousands of young disabled people into employment.

Could young people who are currently exempt from sanctions lose their whole basic benefit? If you’ve been assessed as having limited capability for work-related activity, you can’t be required to look or prepare for work. Under Milburn’s proposals, some young people with that protection today could be required to take part in work or work preparation and risk losing their entire Youth Allowance if they’re judged to be persistently refusing. The report is silent about how long they could go without it and what help, if any, they could get in the meantime. 

Could you be sanctioned for being too ill to take part?
Milburn proposes safeguards for serious acute illness, treatment and crises. How would those safeguards work if a fluctuating condition meant you repeatedly missed appointments, or if you were too unwell to explain what happened?

Milburn says sanctions should be rare. Yet DWP figures show that failure to attend or take part in a mandatory interview accounted for 90.2% of adverse UC sanction decisions in the latest year for which figures were published. What would stop the same pattern emerging under the Youth Allowance? DWP benefit sanctions statistics to August 2026.

Who decides what you can safely do?
If your GP or specialist says a proposed course or work placement could make you worse, who decides what goes into your Participation Plan, your health professional or a work coach? If there is an appeal system would you be exempt from participation whilst you challenged the decision or would you be forced into work or training that was a threat to your health?

What happens if you try work or college and it makes you worse?
You may only find out what a job or course does to your health once you’ve tried it. Could you leave, get financial help quickly and agree a different plan without risking a sanction? Who would make the decision about these issues?  Would it be someone medically qualified or a DWP decision maker with no specialist medical knowledge at all?

How will young people with autism or ADHD manage in mainstream colleges and workplaces?
Many young people living with ADHD and/or autism will have experienced severe bullying and mistreatment at school.  Some will have stopped attending a result, some will have been excluded, often unlawfully.  Will young people have access to specialist provision, smaller groups or individual support where they need it?

And will mainstream colleges and large workplaces genuinely put in place the support they claim to offer, because that is not the experience of many young people with these conditions. 

Will young people with autism and ADHD just be set up to fail and face the loss of their whole youth allowance because they have been forced into work in busy catering or retail environments they could not hope to cope with?

Who will offer jobs that people with fluctuating conditions can sustain?
With conditions such as ME/CFS, fibromyalgia, chronic pain or severe anxiety, you may be able to work some days and be too ill on others. How many employers can offer flexible hours, short shifts or time off at short notice, and what happens if there are no such jobs where you live?

Where are the jobs going to come from?
The Office for National Statistics recorded 2.4 unemployed people for every vacancy in the UK in July to September 2026. How many suitable paid jobs would the proposals actually create, especially in places where vacancies are already scarce? ONS vacancies and jobs statistics for November 2026.

What will employers and colleges be required to do?
Milburn proposes duties for young people alongside hiring targets and incentives for employers. What would make employers and colleges put reasonable adjustments in place, and could a young person turn down or leave a placement if those adjustments weren’t provided? Will there be support for young people who need to take action under the Equality Act to protect their wellbeing?

What happens as AI takes over entry-level work?
Milburn acknowledges that AI could shrink some of the routes young people use to get their first job, including in sectors such as call centres. If employers need fewer people for those roles, where will young people get their first paid work and build the experience other employers ask for?

Will disability support depend on your postcode?
Local areas would have discretion over how to use the proposed Health and Disability Fund. What minimum help could you count on wherever you live, and how would you challenge a refusal if your local fund ran short?

Comments

Write comments...
or post as a guest
Loading comment... The comment will be refreshed after 00:00.

Be the first to comment.

PIP & The WCA Are Changing- Get The Latest News

Stay updated with our free, fortnightly newsletter.

Over 140,000 claimant and professional subscribers.

 
iContact