There has been a massive response to the Modernising Support Green Paper, Stephen Timms, the DWP minister for disability has revealed.  And whilst the government is still not offering any certainty that the proposal to replace PIP cash payments with vouchers will be dropped, they do seem to be distancing themselves from the Conservative’s proposals.

Timms was answering a question on behalf of the secretary of state for Work and Pensions from Labour MP Cat Smith:

“To ask the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, when she plans to publish her Department's response to the consultation entitled Modernising support for independent living: the health and disability green paper, published in April 2024.”

Timms replied:

“The consultation on the Modernising Support Green Paper closed on Monday 22 July. Over 16,000 responses have been received and we will review these responses.

“The proposals in this Green Paper were developed by the previous government. We will be considering our own approach to social security in due course.”

The number of responses is more than ten times higher than were given to the DWP consultation on changes to the work capability assessment, which was launched in September 2023.  That consultation received 1,348 replies.

It is likely that the vast majority of responses will have been negative in relation to most of the proposals for changes to PIP.  It is encouraging to learn that so many people took the trouble to respond and it will have left the government in no doubt about the size of the fight they will have on their hands if they try to push through any of the more controversial ideas in the Green Paper  

The form of words used by Timms “We will be considering our own approach to social security in due course.” is identical to that used by Baroness Sherlock in the House of Lords last week.

Whilst it lacks any certainty, the phrase does suggest that Labour are planning to disown most of what the Conservatives have proposed.

Benefits and Work readers, who we know responded in large numbers to the Green Paper, can congratulate themselves on having spoken out so powerfully on behalf of the many PIP claimants who found the consultation too overwhelming to reply to.

Comments

Write comments...
or post as a guest
People in conversation:
Loading comment... The comment will be refreshed after 00:00.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    geoff and dionne · 2 hours ago
    waiting to find out if we loose pip is likend to making a dog beg for treats,it creates sick anxiety,dependant control,guilt ..now...good people give without guilt or conditions, unconditional love. the sick human gets pleasure from this,ego,power stating its correct training for controlled behaviour shardenfroder.its here now, n.w.o 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Sav · 8 days ago
    They are already having to do a vote on winter fuel allowance,  so maybe they will vote on pip
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Matt · 3 days ago
      @Sav And to add to my comment below, the winter fuel debate has ended with a Labour majority of approx 120.  So if they can withdraw winter fuel allowance, given the vociferous opposition of most of the right wing press (their customers), then imagine what is going to happen to disability benefits.  The DNS and benefits and work have hardly the clout of the Daily Mail or its circulation.  October 30th, and before that Kendall on October 7th, promises to be very grim indeed.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Matt · 3 days ago
      @Sav Problem being that labour have a massive majority of 174. Even if there was a large rebellion (and thus ruining any chance of a ministerial promotion) any plans to reform PIP would get through. It'll be up to the House of Lords to amend, and charities to club together to pursue a Judicial Review (all the way to the Supreme Court, if necessary) but ultimately Parliament is supreme (as I learnt when doing O level Political Studies, formerly British Constitution) back in the mid-80's.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    tinytim · 8 days ago
    As there is also the Motability Scheme Question will this be Abolished as a pensioner On a very small Occupational pension my winter fuel allowance is no more and if this mad Voucher System would be a disaster for many as Catalogues for disability Equipment are already provided by my local county council adult care service.   
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Jon · 1 days ago
      @Matt Liz Kendall is sharing a stage with maximus at the end of September at the labour conference so we might find out then
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Matt · 8 days ago
      @tinytim I don't know but we may get a clearer idea of the Government's intentions on October 7th when Kendall faces parliamentary questions in relation to welfare reform. The White Paper may also have been published by then, and at the end of October we have the Budget which the PM has already advised us peasants will be dire....
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Louise Anne Burke · 15 days ago
    reading these comments back is already divisive. Some on here are saying 'we are truly disabled, it is those who are 'shirkers' that shouldn't be claiming'. But what if every person on PIP thinks that only their claim is legitimate and that reforms should be applied to everyone else but themselves? 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Brian Marriott · 13 days ago
      @Louise Anne Burke Wrong every disability should claim pip not just wot u said I can’t even go out any where as I easily get lost I can’t follow a simple route 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Bill · 18 days ago
    The idea of replacing PIP with vouchers is quite mind boggling. Apart from it probably being unworkable, it's a retrograde step. A step back in time to the post war era of rationing. Although, rationing, not because of a lack of resources but as a method of saving money at the expense of those who can lest afford to lose it.
    And there's the rub. Those who are inactive, due to disability or ill health are, and always have been the easiest targets.
    A voucher system in the 21st century is a policy not worthy of any progressive political party, whatever the colour. 
    It's particularly disconcerting that the Labour Party were quick to scrap the Rwanda scheme but prefer to have a consultation on a policy that will clearly have an impact on so many disabled people 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Jon · 4 days ago
      @Matt If the government push self employment what kind of jobs would the disabled be asked to do
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Matt · 15 days ago
      @A I have mentioned, in a few posts, that the DWP/Government are likely to push self-employment for the sick and disabled as they can work from home. There is no way they will be able to get hundreds of thousands of disabled people into mainstream employment, unless there is very stringent anti-discrimination legislation, and the business community will cut very rough if that is implemented.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      A · 16 days ago
      @Bill You're all focussed on vouchers, when Liz Kendall's target is to remove PIP whether in vouchers, cash, or whatever from as many claimants as possible, as their aim is to cut benefits, because by paying it in vouchers, it'll still cost the same amount of money, if not even more expensive, for the DWP.

      It's not all about vouchers. They're also thinking of making it a one off small payment, providing equipment, therapy, etc. In addition, their aim is also to push as may claimants as possible into poorly paid jobs and take them off from all sorts of benefits.

      Who said that vouchers grow on trees!
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Yasmin · 20 days ago
    The wait to hear about what’s happening with PIP is agonising, seriously it’s making me extremely stressed. I would suggest people politely, but clearly email Liz Kendal and/or Stephen Timms and express how important PIP is to their needs and explain why the voucher system wouldn’t work or claiming back receipts for everything would be utterly degrading and yet another thing for my brain to have to cope with. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Trevor · 3 days ago
      @Yasmin Hi Yasmin, just to put it out there, if they remove the cash payment from us, most of us won't be able to pay our bills so how the hell do they expect us to have money to purchase items and then send in the receipts, it's an absolute disgrace if they do this. We didn't ask to be disabled so does that mean we are worthless and second class citizens. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Primrose · 26 days ago
    Our daughter was diagnosed with Anorexia something she is in recovery with since 2021 she is a survivor of domestic violence and child sexual abuse has suffered horrific CRIME'S against her from a young child something she didn't ask for nor me her mum yet her issues have meant she is now with cptsd social anxiety ocd and austism her vulnerabilities mean at the moment she is unable to be without full support from us as a family has limited life opportunities if she is denied her pip then she will struggle to make any sense of her life. Her perpetrator's who enabled her child sexual abuse were given 2 yrs suspended sentence yet our daughter lives with a life sentence utterly DISGRACEFUL and this government wants to deny genuine cases the right to some sort of life this is why im writing this here as our daughter full time carer while she is in recovery with Anorexia this is a life time mental health illness why we are determined to keep this government realising that pip is our daughter's life line .
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Jasmin · 20 days ago
      @Primrose I’m so sorry about your daughter but this is a powerful reminder of why pip is so needed and why a voucher system would not help her. I suggest you email Liz Kendal and/or Stephen Timms and politely, but clearly write why this is so critical for her, and why a different system would not work, other than the cash benefit. It’s important they realise as well the wait for news is causing, and the anxiety x 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Matt · 26 days ago
    Well, the softening-up process has begun. I wonder if the White Paper will be published before the Budget? Clearly there will be a drive to get as many disabled people into work as possible. Given the reluctance of employers to employ disabled people, the emphasis may be towards self-employment but this will entail needing an accountant/tax expert, some marketing expertise, practical aids (vouchers?) etc. Self employment is bloody hard work, and very rarely pays. There's far more risk than being a wage slave ...
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      mrfibro · 11 days ago
      @Matt Where's all the over 3 million jobs coming from in the first place.  Secondly one needs not the same amount of after tax paid wages, but more due to being disabled, and what that incurs.

      Also there would be mass discrimination, and prejudice  towards disabled people. The workplace would consist of hatred & harassment placed upon disabled people by fellow colleagues.   That alone would cause more unemployment, as the disabled people would not be able to cope with that kind of pressure and stress.

      Liz Kendall & Co, are all in total denial, the hardship disabled people would face if they were forced back into work.




    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Matt · 22 days ago
      @RIL A quick note in relation to self-employment.  I work in the financial services industry and we have done a survey with a disclosure at approximately 40% of those who are self-employed have been the victim of a financial scam/crime. I fear that disabled people, forced into self-employment by the new Government, could be particularly vulnerable to this. Given the very limited chances of anyone being caught, let alone prosecuted, this does not bode well for the future. As well as needing equipment (which costs money, anyone who is self employed will need very good internet security),
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      RIL · 25 days ago
      @Matt I think you’re right in that assessment…. I have been self employed for the last 12 years , The only “feasible” way to get so many disabled people into “work” isn’t going to be through employers - as younpint out employers don’t WANT to employ disabled people. They’ll push some sort of pseudo self employment on disabled people. Watch out for some weird and wonderful “self employment schemes” in the future …  
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    MariW · 27 days ago
    From The Observer

    It’s time to end blame culture over benefits bill, says Labour minister

    Exclusive: Work and pensions secretary Liz Kendall pledges to halt Tory ‘salami slicing’ of benefits, but Labour under fire for union pay deals

    Michael Savage Policy editor

    Sat 17 Aug 2024 19.00 BST

    Share

    Labour will end the blame culture aimed at people out of work and will not repeat the “salami slicing” of the benefits bill pursued by the Tories, the work and pensions secretary pledges today, as she warns that rising welfare spending is unsustainable.

    In her first newspaper interview since taking the role, Liz Kendall told the Observer that a drastic overhaul was required to fix a “broken” back-to-work system, warning that the number of people who are economically inactive was now bigger than the population of London.

    Describing her task as “one of the biggest challenges the country faces”, she said that she would be bringing in major reforms to a system that was failing too many of the near record 2.8 million people now out of work due to long-term sickness.

    She accused a series of Conservative politicians of using anti-welfare rhetoric against people in need of help. Amid concerns within Labour that welfare will be squeezed as part of chancellor Rachel Reeves’s first budget this autumn, Kendall said she would not make reform “merely about cuts and blame”.

    Citing large projected increases in welfare spending, she added: “I do not think it’s sustainable when you’re seeing those levels of increases, but we can do something about it.”

    She criticised the previous government’s approach, which she described as “salami slicing cuts [and] divisive rhetoric that blames people and doesn’t support them.

    “We’ve never seen more people written off. The last parliament was the worst for economic inactivity on record. It is for us to put this right. But we will need big reforms and big changes. I know people worry about this, but I want to say, we are on your side. We are not going to write you off and blame you. We take our responsibilities seriously. We’re going to bust a gut to give you the support you need to build a better life.”

    Reeves has already made it clear that she will make “tough decisions” on welfare spending in the forthcoming budget, describing spending as “out of control”. Over the next six years, spending on incapacity and disability benefits for working age people is projected to rise to £63bn – a real-terms increase of almost 48%. However, some MPs are wary of any squeeze that would only save money in the short term.

    Kendall repeatedly took aim at the rhetoric used by a series of Conservative figures. While former chancellor George Osborne talked about “shirkers”, Rishi Sunak denounced a “sicknote culture”. When he was work and pensions secretary, Mel Stride said some people did not work because they felt “down and bluesy”.



    Chancellor of the exchequer Rachel Reeves will be making ‘tough decisions’ on welfare spending. 

    “All of the talk about strivers versus scroungers or shirkers – I think the people who really shirk their responsibility were the people who last sat in this office because they wrote off millions of people who actually want to work,” Kendall said. “It matters deeply for individuals and their ability to have a decent life for themselves. It matters to our economy because it is the major thing holding back growth. But it also matters to the public finances as well.”

    Plans to curb welfare spending come with the Tories criticising the government for reaching a series of pay deals designed to end strikes. A backdated pay offer for train drivers was announced last week: it followed the chancellor’s £9bn package to increase public sector pay and a major increase offered to junior doctors.

    Stride said his party would “take no lectures from the government, who have failed at the first hurdle to signal that they will get a grip on welfare spending”.

    “Labour have made their priorities clear – taxpayer-funded above-inflation pay rises demanded by their union paymasters and scrapping welfare reform that could save the taxpayer £12bn – all while axing winter fuel payments for pensioners. Without taking much-needed action to make the welfare bill sustainable, Labour will once again ramp up taxes.”


    In a frank assessment of the challenge she faces, Kendall said she was “under no illusions” about the size of her task. She said the current system “is broken. It’s not working. But I know that our work coaches are full of passion and ideas about doing things differently.”

    Kendall suggested there would be serious reforms to jobcentres, freeing them up from monitoring benefits and linking them with the NHS to help those struggling to work for health reasons. “We have got to put jobcentres back to where they were initially meant to be, which is a public employment service,” she said. “That isn’t how they are. Their overwhelming focus is on monitoring, assessing and policing benefits. We’ve got 16,000 work coaches and we want them to do what they say on the tin.”

    She also committed to a review of universal credit, new plans to tackle economic inactivity led by local areas and mayors and a “youth guarantee” ensuring every 18-21-year-old could get training, an apprenticeship or support to find work. More details of her plans will be unveiled in a white paper in the autumn.

    Kendall would not be drawn on whether she was pushing for the Treasury to end the two-child limit on benefits that most experts believe is a driving force behind child poverty. However, the Leicester West MP said that the government’s child poverty taskforce had met for the first time last week and that the issue was a priority.

    “I have got one in three kids in Leicester growing up poor,” she said. “On one of my last visits to one of my primary schools, they’d had to go out to find a young boy who had not been at school. When they found him at home, all he had was a bowl of salad cream for breakfast. I know in my bones how appalling the situation is.

    “I will only make a commitment when I know that we can deliver on it. The last Labour government did incredible things to tackle poverty, but it was so easily overturned by the Tories. We are determined that our strategy will not only take immediate action, but this time it will last.”



  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    D · 29 days ago
    Biggest issue now is Labour making pip means tested - that wasn’t a question asked in the consultation so we haven’t had a chance to explain how bad an idea that would be (compared to the equally terrible voucher idea)

    Or Labour making it next to impossible for those with invisible or neurodivergent to claim pip or disability elements of pip

    Labour already proven that they don’t understand pip
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Brian Marriott · 29 days ago
    When will we get any more news 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      mrfibro · 29 days ago
      @Brian Marriott Obviously when labour find more black holes.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      MariW · 29 days ago
      @Brian Marriott @Brian Marriott I don't think we will have definitive information until the Budget on 30 October. Until then, we only have rumours, some of which may be government leaks. We just don't know, it's a cruelly anxious time. Take care, Mari.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Kevin Jackson · 1 months ago
    I sent my 8 page paper to Caxton House and Mel Stride, It wont make much difference.
    PIP payments are used by all who receive them to pay their way in life.
    We all need cash to pay our way in life, no matter what your circumstances are.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      boris1 · 1 months ago
      @Anon Anon
      Yes Kendall is Minister for work and pensions and she seems to be just as discrinatory as Stride against the disabled community and disability benefits.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      boris1 · 1 months ago
      @Kevin Jackson Mel Stride was an advocate of stopping pip and he said people who felt "down and bluesy" should be forced to take jobs.
      You won't get any support from him.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Anon · 1 months ago
      @Kevin Jackson Mel Stride is no longer the minister for work and pensions, Liz Kendall is.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    JT · 1 months ago
    I am one of those participants who would  have completed the lengthy survey, downloaded as a copy!
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Brian Marriott · 1 months ago
    Pip should be money only as we need the money to pay for taxi and for repairs voucher will not pay for taxi voucher is useless 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Caz · 1 days ago
      @Matt @matt totally agree with you. I too and sick of always living in fear and proving myself over and over again. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Matt · 9 days ago
      @Brian Marriott I believe they will start a revolt if they go ahead with it as it's totally useless and we have told the gov with overwhelming response that it will not work and no one wants it as it is a dangerous and reckless thing Todo I my self have no use for vouchers I do in fact have use for cash like paying my bills !! Im sick of fearing for the right to live they want the disabled gone simple fact 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Anon · 1 months ago
      @Brian Marriott You keep making the same comment over and over again. I understand the anxiety about any possible changes but the Government aren't going to read these comments.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Ana · 1 months ago
    I used to work until my doctors said there was no way with my chronic fibromyalgia epilepsy and arthritis plus suffer from high anxiety, depression and ptsd my money gets used on my daily living expenses also a Motability scooter which is my lifeline i have to watch what i eat and i have multiple chemical sensitivities so i have to be careful with everything i eat or consume, my wet room is upstairs and i need to see about a stair lift , carer and a household help but you cant pay for people to come in with vouchers plus the extra heating in the winter the air in the summer, extra bill money food taxis when you need to get to an appointment in a hurry
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Jack · 1 months ago
    Does anyone have any new information on this as I'm really scared and worried I'm going lose my pip cast payments for vouchers I rely on pip for my carer and a cleaner and other living costs this being stripped away I will fall down hard, I'm having sleepless nights over this I have dyspraxia, Asperger's, epilepsy and anxiety and trying not to make myself sick over this. Any reassurance or information is much appreciated. 🙏
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Jack · 1 months ago
      @CaroA I hope fingers crossed they scrap this ridiculous not thought through plan as usual attack the most vulnerable of society and quietest voices no matter Labour or conservative all the SAME. If you know  any more information I'd greatly appreciate it if you happen to hear anything new to come of this as I'm absolutely petrified. 🤦‍♂️🙏
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      CaroA · 1 months ago
      @Jack Thanks for this Jack I hope you can find some peace during your day.  So many of us are really worried about this but hopefully 🤞 it won't be as bad as we think.  
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    billkruse · 1 months ago
    They won't be changing to vouchers. Think of the additional administration costs for the govt and for retailers! This is a non-starter. Anyway, we already use a voucher of sorts, one issued by the govt redeemable with the govt against taxes which is what gives them their value. Money. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Albert · 7 days ago
      @A Actually your wrong do you know how much and how long if would take and cost to set up this system ? I’m  a software developer believe me this is a massive and expensive task no one individual could oversee this or indeed operate it 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Anon · 19 days ago
      @A While in your head it seems that simple, really world it's not even like that.

      You do understand barcodes store very basic infomation they can't store complex amounts of date. 

      This system would cost more then it would save the government alone in development of software and then getting company's on board with the idea. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      A · 1 months ago
      @billkruse No significant administration cost would involve if they decided to, as it can take only one staff member to issue vouchers to millions of people within less than a minute on a computer, in the form of barcodes, to be sent out via emails or text messages, to scanned at retailers and voila done.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      phil · 1 months ago
      @billkruse Hi Bill, nice to see you on here and I do enjoy your work on that mensa website. About money and the invasion by Holland in the late 1600's. And on R. Murphys blog.
      As you say £££ is already a voucher !
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Mark W · 1 months ago
    I had Encephalitis when I was 23 months old leaving me with several problems although I look OK and sound OK.  People think I am about 16 years when I am actually 45. I use my PIP to pay for my carer who has been organised for me through the local council.  Are the DWP going to drag me in to get me to work (I can't of course). Please don't judge people, there are some who really need help and have done for years.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Billy · 1 months ago
    I have severe neck, shoulder and spine problems. Without pip I would be totally housebound as there is no way I could afford to get around. My mental health isn't good as the pain I'm in is traumatic.  So I would end up staying in all the time as I need to pay to get around. I am really anxious about these changes. Worse than when I had to do the work capability assessment. They always treat disabled people like we are a burden. It's like do u think I would be like this if I had a choice. And they talk about cutting back on money, have u seen how much these politicians spend on themselves and charge to the government,  remember that one guy who charged the government 40 pounds for a breakfast, and he bought expensive boxer shorts on tue governments money. Its such hypocrisy 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Declan · 1 months ago
    I have been claiming benefits since the age I was able to, I have very severe mental health due to past trauma and I also have learning disabilities, those who claim for no reasons should be the ones that pay not the ones that genuinely need the support. I tried working a few times before I actually claimed but I mentally couldn’t cope having intense anxiety attacks. If I was strong enough to I would do it but I’ve tried many times
We use cookies

We use cookies on our website. Some of them are essential for the operation of the site, while others help us to improve this site and the user experience (tracking cookies). You can decide for yourself whether you want to allow cookies or not. Please note that if you reject them, you may not be able to use all the functionalities of the site.